Welsh Newspapers

Search 15 million Welsh newspaper articles

Hide Articles List

5 articles on this Page

THE DISSENTERS AND THE IRISH…

News
Cite
Share

THE DISSENTERS AND THE IRISH CHURCH. TO THE EDITOR OF THE "WELSHMAN." SIR -The obtuseness of your correspondent, D. Herbert," if real, is very extraordinary if assumed, it may be easily accounted for, on the principle that none are so blind as those who will not see." I adduced instances of the practice with which I charged the Dissenters, naming three chapels, in connection with one or more of which I said he might find cases of infants in arms having had their names attached to petitions and I added that I bad then before me the names of children eight and nine years of age which bad been so attached, in connection with one of these chapels, which I particularised. Does the latter asser- tion in any degree invalidate the former ? I really cannot see that it does. Were I to speak of three places, designated as A, B, and C, and to say that certain infants in arms had died at one or more of such places, and then to go on to say that I had the names of children eight and nine years old that bad died at some one of them (say C), this circumstance surely would not weaken the fact of the death of the infants, or warrant the supposition that I had confounded infants in arms with children of a more advanced age. So much for your correspondent's clearness of ideas; unless, as is perhaps more probable, the objection arose from a mere desire of qubbling. However, if it will be more satisfactory to him, I am willing to iepeat my first assertion in its full extent and I cannot help think- ing that he would have taken a more straightforward course had he verified that assertion for himself by enquiries made personally or by letter, instead of in- sinuating, without enquiry, that the facts which I adduced were fictions. I cannot consider myself, in the present case, amen- able to the charge of being a busy-body in other men's matters," as, if Parliamentary petitions are sup- posed to have any weight as exponents of public opinion, their genuineness and good faith must be taken as matters of public importance, and therefore every citizen has a right (if indeed it be not his duty) to hold up to reprobation any departure from these con- ditions. The other expressions of vulgar abuse contained in your correspondent's letter I should pass over without notice, but that I wish to make a few observations on a particular point. It is a curious phenomenon, as re- gards the question of motives, that the good ones are always found on the side of the Dissenters, and the bad as invariably on the side of the church. When the Dissenter vents his grossest calumnies against the church (as he is constantly doing at the present day, witness those scrupulously truthful organs of Dissent, the Baner ae Amserau Cymru and the Tyst Cymrcig), he is of course actuated only by conscientious principles but when a Churchman presumes to open his mouth to point out an evil among the Dissenters, the sole motive by which he can be supposed to be influenced is bigotry, "passion," -or "self-interest" (I quote your correspondent's words). Now were there anything wanting to evince the extreme narrow-minded- ness, as well as the arrogance, of Dissenting vviters it would be this—that they cannot possibly give credit for honesty of motive to any but to those who are of their own way of thinking. According to their liberal theory, Churchmen are to be gagged, and not suffered to say a word in defence of their church, or towards repelling the assaults of her enemies. I now take leave of your correspondent, and remain, Yours truly, HONESTAS. -h-

CARDIGAN GOAL.

I THE WEEK ABROAD.

CARMARTHEN GRAMMAR SCHOOL.

THE WEEK AT HOME. !