Welsh Newspapers

Search 15 million Welsh newspaper articles

Hide Articles List

8 articles on this Page

--Agricultural Co-operation.

News
Cite
Share

Agricultural Co-operation. THE ROYAL COMMISSION ON SEEDS. AN EXPOSURE. [BY AUGUSTUS BRIGSTOCKE]. We licne that now all the farmers are about i br their eeCl, they will pay some heed to the report of the Royal Seed Commission issued as recently as 1901. This report is cram full of instruction of the most practical kind for the farmer, but as it contains more than 250 large quarto pages of closely printed matter, only a small portion of it can be dealt with ia the limits of this article. The conclusion that one irresisi.ib!y arrives at is, t!vit no better way 1,) with the problem discussed can pnssiblv be th.) ii by the formation of Co-o-ierativo Societies'. whk*! will undertake to sell to tueir menbers seeds oc guaranteed germination, purity and weight. In Sco land this course has been adopted with "grp.'t sr. by the Farmer's ,V r. ».'• iiie secvecaiy, u y j 1 would take us too far out of the rne we propose fal- lowing cu dwell on this part of the report. What will interest us most is to hear what evidence was given as to the seed trade in Wales, especially in South-West Wales. Anyone who cares to do so can obtain a copy of the report, therefore .ve abstain from dis- posing the names of the witnesses whose evidence we qujte for ob%:OLIS :velsorls. A ii *.tnns representing a larie wholesale firm of repute, gave evidence whicn should afford food for reflection for many a long day to come. Speak'ng of Carmarthenshire and the adjoiring counties, he said that much of the seed sold is very inferior, in fact that it was a grave scandal to see such stuff in the dealers' shops. Everything seemed to be sacrificed to cheapness, and farmers dia not seem, to care what they bought as long as they bought it cheap. They bought cleanings which many other people would reject, the dealers mixing then with a little good seed, more than half the bulk being absolutely worthless. Witness had never in the course of 27 years' experience heard of any dealers being prosecuted for selling doctored seeds under the Seeds Adulteration Act, as he did not think that thp farmers even knew that such an Act existed for their protec- tion. A great quantity of dved seeds were sold. For example trefoil mixed with clover is dyed to represent clover. The farmer does not care to go over 6d a lb for his see i. It does not matter whether there is a scarcity of clover, as there is this season he tries to get it cheap all the same consequently he gets a good dl'.tl of trefoil passed off on him as genuiue clover. Three parts trefoil perhaps will be found, the market value of which would he considerably less than 'half that of clover. What I most object to, said the witness, is that thines should be sold with impunity, representing to be what they are not. It is a scandal to the trade. The sort of stuff alluded to, with clean- ings, blowings and old seed is largely sold in towns I could mention during the spring of the year. You mirrht get into lialf-n dozen shops in Carmarthen and finu a ton or two of I .is stuff Asked if he could men- tion other places, witness replied yes, also at Lam- peter, Llandovery, Llanvbyther, Newcastle-Emlyn, Tregaron, and other places. The trade has gone down in the place I mention o.ving to the sale of such stuff as I have spoken of. Witness said that the shops that went in for poor seed made it their business to get rid of it somehow, and generally succeeded, as the farmers were very confiding in the matter of buying seeds. Some samples obtained from shopkeepers were produced, containing a large mixture ot dyed aeiuu, and sold as English red "lover. Another witness, as illustrating the child-like confidence of the farmer in such matters, cite 1 cases in which, having asked for a. certain seed, were given something quite different, and were 11 liable io get any remedy. One farmer asked for turnip seed, and was given greystoiie another asked for turnip seed and was given rape, and did not find out the difference until he had grown his crop. One of the principal witnesses was Mr Alfred 0. Wat- kins, the manager of the Irish Agricultural Wholesale Society, and both this witness and others gave very striking evidence in proof of the great protection affor- ded to the farmers by the establishment of Co-opera- tive Societies, who made it their business to see that the farmers got the genuine arlicle whatever the price paid. The Irish Agricultural Wholesale Society were the only firm who made a practice of giving a full guarantee as to germination, purity, and weight, and most interesting particulars were given as to the manner in which this guarantee was carried out. Some of the witnesses representing other firms said that the giving of this guarantee was a new idea introduced by the Co-operative Societies. Mr Watkins, in the course of his e"idence, stated that unfortunately the seed trade is handled by a great many persons who have no technical knowledge of it whatever in any shape or form, such as shopkeepers, hardware merchants, 'hucksters (and, we might add, in Wales, travelling butter merchants, and those who sell outside public- houses). The seeds so sold are in many cases the cleanings and winnowings from the stock of legitimate seed merchants, and the price charged is often, espe- cially where credit is given, almost as high as that for which genuine seeds can be obtaineJ. The infel ior seeds are taken, unfortunately, — the fiiriiier is contf,,t, •. In the case of pei'.v v class of dealers rc^-rc. i. i blowings of light seed. The effect is that the hay pro- duced is of a wretched soft character. The crop is principally Yorkshire fog, a useless grass upon which cattle don't thrive, and the hay is of the poorest quality. Mr Watkins, in reply to one of the Com- missioners, stated that it was a fact that nine-tenths of the perennial rye grass seed used all over the world is grown in Ireland. All seeds sold by the Irish Agri- cultural Wholesale Society on guarantee were tested at the request of any purchaser from their own sample a sent to Dr Steb'ler (Zurich) to be tested. The fee c ed only 3s. A deduction was made in the pri charged for the seeds if Dr Stebler's report dis- clo- 'd any deficiency on the guarantee. Such tests were often made at the request of Co-operative Socie- ties, who were their principal customers. Mr H. Lindsay, the secretary of the Farmers' Supply Associa- tion of Scotland, also sent their seeds to be tested by Dr Stebler (Zurich), who has a European reputation as a specialist in this line. Several other witnesses drew attention to the evil of seeds being sold under false name and representation, and also to the grievous lo s indicted on farmers in the sale of si I-,icli I not been properly cleaned, and which, therefore,didgreatdamage to the land byintroducing all kinds of,weeds. It was also given in evidence that so-called" seed bought by retailers for 5d a bushel were sold to the farmers at Is 6d a bushel, a profit of over 300 per cent. on absolute rubbish. Another important disclosure was made in reference to what is known as the non-warranty clause. We have already referred to the fact that it was givea in evidence that the Irish Agricultural Wholesale Society were the only firm tha.t made a practice of eiving a guarantee with the sale of their seeds. The Commissioners' report on this was as follows (page 10, paragraph 41) « Nearly all the seedsmen insert in their catalogue what is known as the non-warranty clause somewhat in the following terms We give no warranty expressed or implied as to the description, or productiveness, or any other matter on any seeds or other goods sold by us, and we will not be responsible tfor any failure in the crops. It is doubtful, add the Commissioners, whether this non-warranty clause, 'unless especially brought to the notice of the purchases at the time of sale, would release the vendor 'from his legal responsibility. Just so. But how many Welsh farmers are there who would seize their lega( opportunity ? The state of things as disclosed by this report in the seed trade cannot possibly be too widely known, or too often used, as a co-operative text. The exposure of the methods of the retailers of seeds especially in Carmarthenshire and Cardiganshire, would, if made by any private individual, meet with -such an outcry of injured innocence that we should never hear the last of it. But coming from an official source of this kind the indictment is unanswerable. "Strong measures were suggested by several of the witnesses, as for example the appointment of Govern- ment inspectors, and the licensing of all retailers of •seeds. Space will not allow dealing one by one with the 56 paragraphs of the report proper. It must suffice to state that the Commissioners attached the greatest importance to the efficiency, protective and educational value of Co-operative Societies, and paid a high tribute to the splendid work of the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society. The value of local seed-testing stations was also commended, and the Commissioners recommended the establishment of a central Government seed-testing station, which, by the publicity of its reports, would deter wholesale seed merchants with a reputation to lose passing on ■their loft-sweepings to the thieving retailers of the same.

Advertising

-------.----ICarmal thenshire…

Ammanford Urban Council.

-------Carmarthen County Court.

LAUCHARNE.

L LAIF AIR-CL YDOCAU.

Advertising