Welsh Newspapers

Search 15 million Welsh newspaper articles

Hide Articles List

19 articles on this Page

THE COAL CRISIS.I .

News
Cite
Share

THE COAL CRISIS. Men in Conference. I LEADERS CRITICISED. Asked to Resign. A REVOLUTIONARY PROPOSAL Overwhelming Rejection. ¡ A conference oi delegates representing the miners of South Wales and Monmouthshire was was held on Monday at the St. John's Hail. Car- diff, and proved to be one of the most exciting witnessed for many years. It will be remem- bered that at the conference on Mon- day week the delegates declined to give their representatives plenary powers to renew the Scale agreement, hue instructed them to seek another interview with the employers and report the result to this conference. Pending the arrival of Mr W. Abra- ham, M.P. (Mabon), who telegraphed that he could not arrive before noon, the chair was occnpied during the early part of the pro- cenftiuga fay Ht DavKt Morgan, the vice-chairman, and the other members of the Scale Committee bzesent were Messrs Daronwy Isaac, T. Richards. Alfred Onions. John Davies, John Thomas, D. Beynon, D. Morgan (Anthracite), Evan Thomas, D. Thomas, and Lewis Miles (the secretary). The teUentwere Messrs W. Williams, Tylorstown, and W. Traharne. Abertillery. ADMISSION OF THE PRESS. There was a. long discussion as to whether representatives of the Press should be admitted. but eventnatty the delegates—having a lively recollection doubtless of the full and correct reports secured by the reporters of the last conference, which was declared "private"—re- by 59 against 38 to admit the reporters. Another resolution come to was that no one tbofttd speak bat once on any subject, but that Jhe time of each speech be not limited. TBCE RÐLY OF THE EMPLOYERS. Mr LewilJ Miles submitted to the conference a. written report setting forth what had transpired between ue workmen and coaJowners at their bKenieJron Friday last. Sir Wm. T. Lewis on that occasion had, it was reported, said that the men's plana for a minimum in the Scale of 10s per ton to.b. was inadmissible"; that the demand for a Scale giving 10 per cent. rise and j Ian In wages on every shilling change in the prioe of coal was monstrous "—(laughter)—and that as to the Claim for a substantial advance in ipges on the 1st of April, the employers declared Uia± even if the audit had taken place the increase due on the 1st of April wonld be a small one. {Ntwemployers declared they could not proceed with the negotiations until the workmen were prepared to give somebody plenary powers to aetueon their behalf. (A Voice They never will/*) The notices terminating the Scale and the Contracts had been extended nntil the 9th of April, so that the men should have time to WJot;, if they thought desirable, on the question whether their representatives should have plenary sewers OJ: not. A meeting of the Sliding Scale Joint Committee had been arranged for Satur- day next to receive the result of the conference, pd it was agreed that any settlement arrived at fhoold date as from the 1st of April. WHIPPING THE LEADERS. Mr DAVID MOBGAX said that the question at I (MOB seemed to him to be whether the conference woold that <3ay give plenary powers or whether they would refer the question to ballot. (Voice Neither.") The delegates, of course, had a per- fect right if they desired to criticise the action of theif representatives on the Scale Committee. If Ihey ^aetfed to give them a good whipping, well, let them do so. and perhaps they would be all the better fe: it. (Laughter.) Mr TOM RICHARDS, who followed, said that if J the cljaitmau had by his long experience and the many whippings he had received become so hard- enedto the whipping process that he should be so ready to invite the application of the whip that morning, he (the speaker) desired the conference to know that he was a very restive animal, and could not stand the whip at *11. As far as he was con- cerned, he did not invite the whip, nor aid. he think that that would be the best way to get the cart up hill at the present moment. (Hear, hear.) If they had some of the horses IIickiAg it would take them some time to change I the team, and many other things might happen before they could reach the top. If there was any dissatisfaction at all it would hover, he thought, thomt THE EXTENSION OF NOTICES. Be was prepared to put up with a little dissatis- faction of that sort, for it would show that the ■ten were, strong rather than weak. The notices terminated in the middle of the week, and they I left, as they felt in local disputes, that it would be bettor to work the week oat rather than stop in the middle. Thus they aaked to extend the notices until next I Saturday, and the employers urged that if they extended them at all they should extend them until'Saturday, the 9th. so as to give plenty of time to exhaust all means of settlement before proceeding to a stoppage. If there was any justification at all for the extension of I the notices it was to be found in that fact. It was no sign of weakness On their part, but ii they showed any weakness at alf let them show it before they began the fight. They might depend upon it if the fight came about they would be none the weaker in the eyes of the public for having extended the notices to continue the negotiations. As their representativesOA'fche Scale they had felt themselves in a very humHia-ting position, not so much because of anything the conference had done as because of the interpretation which the employees put upon the decision of the „ conference. He was glad to find Mr Brace declaring in his speech an Saturday that the refusal to jrant'plenarv powers was simply a part of their policy, and was not in the slightest degree a reflection upon the members of the Sliding Scale Committee individually or collectively. (Hear, heai1, and cheers.) If that were so, then all right, but if if were not so, then let the men say so as early as possible. If they had no con- fidence ia their representatives the sooner they 8id.80 the better. At this juncture Mabon, M.P., arrived, and Mr David Morgan at once vacated the chair in his f*v»ur. ATTITUDE OF THE SCALE MEMBERS Mr T. RrCIIABDS, proceeding, said that Sir WiBiani T: Lewis told them at the Sliding Scale Conrimttee that he sympathised very much with the representatives of the men because they had faffed to get what their constituency required, and were practically set aside. This meant, of C011rse, that they did not represent the workmen. If that were so—well, be ",1\ ih no way inclined to leave the ship when there were any dangers about, but if Be and his col&'agucj were not the men to see this matter throcgh. then let them be changed by all means. (Hear; hear. T Mr "DASO*.WY IsA-tc said he was but a very ra significant member of the Sliding Scale Committee, but he did not want to remain a atefliB^on stttffcrance. If the refusal of plenary powers was tantamount to a vote of no conn- dence, he "was not anxious for the honour of I representing any longer. He appreciated the honour, but he was not going to PPfcM.rn it at the expense of humiliation. They had I been told-by the employers that they were merely a ptyft of agitators, inciting the workmen to ask far things which they did not want at all. And when they were accused on the other hand fey fch? workmen of being sleeping partners with the employers, the position was by no means tB enviable one. He wished it to be clearly under w&oddbY the Rhondda. miners that he was not anxious ftrkcep his position on sufferance. Mr Omovs AND Mr JOaN Tøoøus spoke to the lame effect. r "-A SPLENDID POLICY. Mr DMorgan said he believed that in with- ftnljrnrr plftrvaury powers the men were pursuing a pa]jf»y and not in any way expressing no confi- dence in their representatives. He would go tBTtber and sav it was a. splendid policy, ana he Whiy approved of it. He did not care whether arthay had. a slap in the face from Sir William Be gggeed-entireiy with the decision already come to by delegates on the plenary power question. Dey had gone to the employers on previous Occasions with plenary powers, and felt over- weifthted" with the responsibility, and the em. ployars took cowardly advantage of the responsi- bility cast upon ns. It would therefore be no getleeti on at all on the representatives to with- hold plenary powers now. CENSURE PROPOSED: A REVOLUTION ARY MOTION. The International Colliery delegate created a •Ood deai of sensation by declaring that he bad been instructed by his colliery to move— (1) A vote Of censors ou the Sliding Scale japresentatives for their action not only since the last conference- but since the crisis began. 2. To yequeat them to stand a?ide so as to permWothers to be ereeted in their place. 3. That notices of tDe flection with the address of tW new secretary be sent to Mr Dalaiel, with an intimation that the new representatives are 18ady to nMet tkK* employers whenever the impl.v.L:r-i are ready 10 dispense with plenary 4. we pos»ilively rsiaas to ta&w a ballot. 5* That we decline the extension of notices. 6 That we advance our demands to 12j Wu,t. on the shilling, with an ucmediate advance in 20 per cent. TteJ proceeded to criticise the action ,1 the .Ji=-lierl)i.jiÜ'.iW¡llja.Ul, he said, travelled f^Qin tk&lhmd to Cardiff with the intention of <C&ivinK the point as to plenary powers, but B tkc wav he received e. tip from someone, and he theii changed his tactics and decided to i«m*n<2 a; baUot. The workman's representatives kaehfsni0^ tograsp the situation at its true value Mforything to the present being an op- ^>Hiriii1T o» lifetime for advancing what were very moderate demands on their part. They had swallowed Sir W. Thomas Lewis's words, had taken their cue from that instead of digesting his actions. His own opinion was framed when the employers put forth their counter proposals, for he then said We are going to win, for no men would be mad enough to make such outra- geous demands unless they were frightened." The speaker, continuing, accused the Sliding Scale members of wasting the time of the people whom they represented by calling them to con- ference after conference. SIR WILLIAM MASTER ON BOTH SIDES. Another charge was that they appeared to be enti rely dominated by Sir William. It was dis- gusting to see the way in which he was master of the house on both sides, for they could not see why one man should boss the whole establishment, They could scarcely take up a newspaper but that there was some peremptory message from him either direct or indirect concerning these plenary powers. It had come to this in the Garw Valley, hat the very sound of plenary powers gave them the shivers. (Laughter.) He asked that the conference pass a, vote of censure on their present representatives, and ask them to stand aside during the present conference. The resolution having been seconded, OTHER PROPOSALS. A Mountain Ash Delegate said he had another resolution to the same effect passed by a mass meeting of 3,000 men. The tesolution passed at this meeting was that they ask their representa- tives to stand aside and that they elect men from the conference to represent them. (Hear, hear.) The big meeting which bad come to this conclu- sion then resolved that if new representatives were elected they should invest them with certain powers. They were not condemning the Sliding Scale members, but they condemned them as a body because they had not to their best interests represented tuem asworkingmen. They had heard some of them say that they could not get a better Scale than they had had in the past. (Cries of "Shame.) Well, if they did not have abetter one than they had had in the past they were better without a. Sliding Scale at all. He believed, and it was the feeling in his district, that a better Sliding Scale could be obtained. (Hear, hear.) He, as a worker, remembered days before any Sliding Scale existed, and he could tell them that they were not so much worse off without the Sliding Scale than they had been with it. The Plymouth Delegate said he had come to the conference with two resolutions. The first was— That we condemn the action of the repre- sentatives in asking the employers to extend the notices, feeling that they have exceeded their duties; and that we do not ask for another meeting with the employers. The next was :— That, in the face of the large majority against plenary powers, we strongly object to a ballot and that we adhere to the resolution of our last conference. (Applause.) A DELEGATE Haa this conference power to dispense with the present representatives on the Scale ? Were they not elected by the body of men by ballot ? I am afraid that we have no power. We from Monmouthshire have no instruc- tions. Our position is not one of antagonism to the representatives, but against their policy. (Hear, near.) MABON'S answer to the question was that the conference had no such power. [A Voice We question that, Mr Chairman." Cries of Order "Fairplay all round!"] Mabon essaying to speak again, further interruption arose but on a further call for order, he was heard quietly, and proceeded to state that whilst the conference had no such power; nevertheless, if those representing the Cambrian Association were willing to accept the responsi- bility, he was willing to abide by the conse- quences. (Hear, hear.) Daronwy nodded assent. MABOX, having repeated in Welsh his statee ment, demanded fair play for every speaker, and the debate proceeded. An Aberaman Delegate said that if the repre- sentatives would not negotiate without plenary powers they should be asked to resign. He pro- ceeded to refer to the question of the audit, but MABox recalled the meeting to the question before the meeting—that of the vote of censure. A Cambrian Association Member declared they had perfect confidence in their members on the Scale. A Risca Delegate believed their represen- tatives should have no plenary powers that day, but the question most be re- ferred to ballot let them not, for God's sake, be divided in that conference. He feared they had not. taken into account the seriousness of the position. If their representatives were to go before the employers again,let them go backed by the full confidence of the men. A Tredegar miner moved as an amendment to the vote of censure that the report of the re- presentatives be adopted, and that the con- ference express its confidence in their represen- tatives. The conference had no power to dismiss the services of their representatives. This was seconded. Several speakers urged that the conference had no right to discuss the removal of the repre- sentatives, if they were elected by districts. If we are going to pass a vote of censure at all, said the next speaker, it should be on the employers. We have every confidence in our representatives. DROPPING INTO THE EMPLOYERS' NET." Mr BRACE said that the conference WóÜ dropping nicely into thai, little uet which the employers had spread for them. The employers had practically declared that they would not object to receiving any board of repre- sentatives other than the Sliding Scale members, a,nd the first thing the conference was doing was to discuss the change of representatives. This was what Sir William had anticipated—that they should divide their forces over this question, and forget all about their demands, so that the employers would be able to exploit them just as they liked. fHeav, hear.) This was not a time to discuss personalities. They were perhrpa within their rights in discussing a vote of censure, but he questioned whether by doing so they were advancing the best interests of the men whom they represented. He should fight as strongly as anyone against plenary powers. He was deadly opposed to it on principle, and he was glad the vice-chairman (Mr David Morgan) was himself on that side, and it was because he (the speaker) believed that the leaders would be weak- ened and not strengthened that he was against granting them plenary powers. A Tylorstown Delegate urged that a vote of censure at that time was untimely. SPEECH BY MABON. The CHAIK.UA.N declared that the vote of cen- sure had been forced upon the conference, and it was now his duty to put it to them and ask them to vote for or against. If he as chairman had ruled that proposal out of order it was very likely, that some of them would go round and say that he and his colleagues on the Sliding Scale were afraid to test their own conference. He did not think is would have been manly on the part of the repre- sentatives to shirk the responsibility. Delegates present that had niandates from the colliery they represented would of course vote in accordance with the instructions they had received, and if not, of course chey would have to vote as they themselves believed right. It would appear that the greatest sin of the representatives was the suggestion to lengthen the time in order that their desire might be tested by ballot on the question of plenary powers. MTGAKDINF-R(Abertillery) maintained that some reason should be brought forward for this vote of censure. Mr HS^TKY DAvas s, Cwmama-N. then moved a direct negative in the following terms :— That this conference agrees that the most unqualified confidence be placed in our represen- tatives on the Sliding Scale, and that a hearty vote of thanks be given them for their efforts on our behalf as working men. This was seconded, and amid cries of Vote. vote," a Delegate at the rear of the hall declared that he could not vote unless he had first con- sulted the workmen whom he represented. MABON I expect every man to vote upon this question, either for or against the resolution. We don't want. to occupy your time with any defence, but will leave th^ delegates to decide the matter. A vote was then taken, with the following result:— For the vote of censure 15 Against 70 Majority 55 This result was received with eheering, and the conference then adjourned until 215.

!AFTERNOON PROCEEDINGS,

SWANSEA RAILWAYMEN.

A FINE ART.

Advertising

MINERS' PROVIDENT FUND.

LLANDAFF FIELDS.

MR GILBERT AND THE " ERA."

Advertising

I Mr E. R. Moxey, J.P. I.…

Advertising

THE RECENT EXCAVATIONS.

ELECTION OF GUARDIANS.

DEATH OF THE REV.DR^DAVIES,…

LOCAL LAW CASE.

[No title]

Advertising

- CARDIFF BIGAMY CASE.

Advertising