Welsh Newspapers

Search 15 million Welsh newspaper articles

Hide Articles List

9 articles on this Page

COUNTY APPEAL TRIBUNAL.

News
Cite
Share

COUNTY APPEAL TRIBUNAL. An Unusual Incident. Brcccushire Appeal Tribunal had a long at Brecon on Thursday. The members ■Jfcsent vrerc Messrs. D. T. Jeffreys (chairman), yfvan-Tliomiis, E. Butler. W. R. Miller. W. W any deWititon, J. D. Morgau aud James v?rgan (Brynmav/r). the ease of Mr. W. Evans, clerk and secretary to the Brecoushire War {^cultural Executive Committee, which had r !l adjourned for another medical examina- it was reported tljat the applicant had "11 put in Grade I. I "ta Chairman, to Mr. David Jones (chair- pri of the War Agricultural Executive j \t %llnittee): Are there any new facts you I ('ul(l like to place before us V | Jones None, sir, that I know of. *°u have addressed a letter to the Tribunal, 1 ^hich you speak of increased work thrown Doll yon hy the Proclamation V—Yeij. p ^Ir. ]\riller. vho is a member of the Execu- | Committee, informs us thai Mr. Havard ^fHanis las now instructed Mr. Proper that J e nor to Lrive the whole of his tinis ?—Yes. I therefore more work falls on the applicant V he will have more work to do. j Mv. C. W. Best, X. S. representative The j new fact wifh which I am concerned is t the man is now Grade I. and wtch men-! *a»ted. *tr\ Evans I have been twice rejected, Iv a medical board, and I offered myself ^Untarily. The Tribunal considered the case in private. u their return the Chairman said In this liai-in,, regard to the pressure of work j devofving upon the Agricultural Com- ^tee aud the need and importance of that j tTk- we grant temporary exemption for three j the afternoon Mr. Best applied for per- J^ipu to appeal to the Central Tribunal on .e ground, first, that a member of the War %icultural Executive Committee fjai aud ^Micated on the case and, secondly, that a '^y to the application was admitted to the hearing, whilst the National Service ^esentative was not. I Chairman Who was admitted ? ),¡ Arr. Best: Mr Miller sat and adjudicated and '1'. Miller was admitted to the private hearing Private consultation. t fter a brief consultation with his colleagues Chairman said We refuse your application, u1"' Best. You knew at the time that Mr. \¡1.l1er was a member of the War Agricultural eelitin-e Committee. You took no objection hllS cittiii, we assumed consent on your part, the ^judication was unanimous. L^r. Best said he was-not aware ia the morn- ^thal Mr. Miller was a member of the War lturaI Executive Committee. If he had IlSu k he would have raised his objection ml 1 thiulc i* right," added Mr. Best, to it quite clear that I have not acted, in any w iu bad faith I would not do that for the Md." -Tlic- Chaii-m,-tli I quite understand your I Point. but obiectiou not having been taken we l'efU2 leave io ie IlEC RURAL DECISION REVBRSED. C* employer of Charles Marshall, 42, I., married, farm bailiff at Pytindu, agaift'st the refusal of the Brecon Tribunal to give further exemption. Mr, J Jones appeared for his nephew (Captain D. (3rd the employer, and mentioned that the tl erfor cultivation was 0;2 acres, and hitherto ik;' I jn te Ild only been one regular man (aged 60) t, a farm of acres besides Marshall. From [ Ik*16 *° time they had had soldier labour and an ex^ra man since April 1st. ^plying to Captain Wilson, N.S. repre- •^tative; Mr. Jones said 110 attempt had been to employ women 011 the Pytindu land. t, C,ti)taiii 'NVil,,)ii Does not Marshall occupy Ost of his time in the garden ? Jones No, you do not have a man at J a year with keep for himself and wife to time in a little bit of a kitchen garden. \,The Chairman, addressing Mr. Jones, said y ^thiis weighed with us is the time you J^self give to national work in this county, the fact also that your nephew id serving, nyjst be some keen man remaining to > ^age the farm, and we therefore grant your ( a'1 exemption till September 1st on ground A of national importance). LOST ON TWO GROUNDS. t ^r. Phillips, of Gludy Farm, Brecon, applied Kp further exemption for Lewis Morgan M0Pkins, 19, Class B II., waggoner and ^ghman. till Chairman We granted you exemption May Fair so that you could get another lwir. Phillips He is the only man I have. tyjhe Secretary (Mr. H. F. W. Harries) said Question arose as to the description of the (j, ou his registration card. If he was not .6!-e described as an agricultural worker he under the Proclamation and could only ^elf appeal on personal grounds. 6 Tlve Chairman Apart from that we met the Mover's convenience by granting exemption H. May 1st to give him an opportunity to get J°ther man. This man is not a skilled ^ghman. Phillips He is a B II. man and that is reason I kept him oil. Chairman If he is registered as a Ii on his registration card we have no go t to hear the case, and apart from that on J4 Merits we dismiss the appeal. tILTH RURAL CASE UNDER THE PROCLAMATION. \y^rs. Weale, a,s the emploj-er of Ivor Price itl eale, 19, Class A, waggoner and farm bailiff, J the Builth Rural district, appealed for L.^ption. and the application was supported Mr. Lewis W. H. Jones, solicitor, Brecon. K Secretary This man comes within the a tarnation, and when the local .Tribunal v.yt with the case 011 April 22nd they had no to do so. V^r. C. W. Woosnam, N.S. representative ilh. Agricultural Executive Committee have withdrawn the blue voucher in this The Chairman You have the right to go to 11 the Agricultural Executive Committee and ask for a certificate to enable you to come to us. MEDICAL RE-EXAMINATION CONCEDED. Mr. Jenkin Williams. Sennybridge: wished to make an application in the case of Arthur Brown, 23, Class A, single, a timber haulier, but the Secretary said the case came within the Proclamation. Mr. Jenkin Williams said on a previous medical examination the man was placed in a lower grde, and in view of his physical defects he asked for an order for a further examination. The Secretary Mr. Williams cannot make that application. The man must make it unless there is good reason shown to the Tribunal otherwise. Captain Wilson said he would consent to another examination on condition that if it resulted again in Class A the man went to the Army. I The Chairman He cannot help himself. WITH A WIFE AND NINE CHILDREN. The local Tribunal having granted further I temporary exemption, with leave to apply again, on the ground of hardship, to Gwilvm Rees Price. 33. married, witi nine children, a colliery haulier,Colonel J. J. Jones, N.S. repre- sentative, appealed. In reply to questions, the respondent said he had not had any notice of comb out." His oldest child was under 12 aad the ydungest 18 months. His earnings were 13 13s. he knew the separation allowance would be £ 2 Gs., but that was different to having a man at home raising his family. He had been working underground many years, but was out of the coHiery for a short time in 1914, and therefore I his case did not come under the jurisdiction of the Colliery TFibutial. The case was adjourned for respondent to be medically examined. WILLING TO ABIDE THE ISSUE. Mr. F. S. Simons, solicitor. Cefn and Merthyr, on behalf of Thomas Powell. 39, Bl, married, pit carpenter, applied for further exemption, and fer another medical examination. He said the applicant was twice graded C3. at Brecon and Cardiff. Later a travelling Medical Board put him in Bl, but most people who were »raded Bl by that Board were afterwards rejected as medically unfit. He thought it would be more satisfactory to deal that day with the application for examination. The Chairman You are willing to stake your all on the medical examination ? Mr. Simons Yes. Another medical examination was ordered. HAYING REGARD TO THE CIRCUMSTANCES: David Davies. 39, Bl, married, with nine children, appealed against the refusal of a local Tribunal to grant further exemption, on the ground of hardship. After listening to the man's story of his family circumstances the Chairman said :— Having regard to your medical category, the number of your children, and the cost you would be to your country, we grant you six months' exemption on the ground of hardship. EVERYBODY SATISFIED. Mr. F. S. Simons, as the employer of Charles Gardner, 39, Grade 3, a married gardener, of Cefn, appealed against the decision of the local Tribunal attaching to temporary exemption the condition that the man took up work of national importance other than ordinary garden- ing. Colonel Jones The man being Grade 3, I don't know that he would be very much good to the Army, but the point is. that lie is to do work of national importance. Mr. Simons said the man worked an acre of vegetable garden, and managed a farm of six acres. Colonel Jones Having regard to the cir- cumstances, I don't see any advantage in changing his occupation. He is quite as well where he is. The Chairman We quite agree. Conditional exemption on Ground A. FEEDING THE FARiUERS" AT BUILTH. The N.S. representative reviewed the certi- ficate of conditional exemption held by Mr. F. L. Morris, 33, Grade 2. grocer, baker, and pro- vision merchant, of Builth Wells, in partner- ship with his father. Mr. G. Tudor, solicitor, Brecon, appeared for the respondent. In the course of his statement as to the nature and extent of the business, Mr. Morris mentioned that the firm had a restaurant, and extra help was engaged there on market days. Captain Wilson What extra help ? Mr. Morris Women to wait on the farmers feeding. (Laughter.) The turnover of the business having been mentioned, the Chairman observed: It is progressive, notwithstanding the rations. (Laughter.) Mr. Tudor The increase is accounted for by the rise in prices. I don't think there is any extension of business. After a private deliberation the Tribunal withdrew the exemption, but directed that Mr. Morris was not to be called up before June 30th. JOINED UP. It was reported that the application in the case of Mr. William Watkin Morgan, of Pen- kelly Court, assistant machinery and. horse officer to the War Agricultural Executive Com- mittee, had been withdrawn. The case had been adjourned for a medical examination, which resulted in Grade 1, and Mr. Morgan has joined up." FORFEITED HIS RIGHT. Mr. Thomas Davies. 42, Grade 3. single, cabinet-maker, of Sennybridge, applied for further exemption, It was stated that appli- cant had not taken up work of national impor- tance, as directed. Captain Wilson He would be very valuable in aeroplane work. I The Chairman told the applicant that he had not fulfilled the condition imposed, and he had forfeited his right of appeal. <

Advertising

Advertising

Breconshire Lighting Times.…

A CALL FROM MHOWI

RHEUMATISM KIDNEY TROUBLE

Agriculture and Recruiting:—…

Advertising

COUNTY APPEAL TRIBUNAL.