Welsh Newspapers

Search 15 million Welsh newspaper articles

Hide Articles List

28 articles on this Page

MOREWOOD'S WORKS.

OUR VOLUNTEER CORPS. I

"TEMPEST TOSSED" AT THE ROYALTY…

THE NEW POSTAL REGULATIONS.

ACCIDENT TO ONE OF MESSRS.…

QUARTERLY MEETINGS OF BAPTISTS.I

A FORTHCOMING CONCERT. I

VIOLIN RECITAL AT THE PARISH…

-I THE SCHOOL BOARD RATE.…

LOCAL CRICKET NOTESI

CRICKET MATCHES. I

THE JENNINGS' MEMORIAL FUND.

IFATAL ACCIDENT AT CWM I CAPEL…

ST. DAVIDS CHURCH, LLANELLY.I

MATTERS AT KIDWELLY. I

I AN EXCITING CHASE.

RIGHTEOUSNESS EXALTETH A NATION.

RAILWAY PLATFORM.

MAGISTRATES' COURT.

THE PEARL LIFE ASSURANCE I…

I SHOP ASSISTANTS' UNION.…

i LOCAL SCHOOL BOARD.

A THOROUGH INVESTIGATION FOR…

MR. TENNYSON 8IITH ? AND…

News
Cite
Share

MR. TENNYSON 8IITH AND HIS METHODS. I A REJOIXDER FROM MR. JOHN I WILLIAMS. TO TTIE EDITOR. ¡ SIR,—In Mr. Valentin's reply to my letter of the 22nd, there is no lack of bounce 01' presumptuous brag, but for even the shadow of a refutation you may look and look in vain. He has apparently substituted assertion for proof, and arrogance for argument. He says it would be an easy matter for me to show the absurdity and incorrectness of Mr. Williams' arguments, &c. but easy as the task is, he feels unequal to it, and has delegated the work to the secretary of the County Brewers' Society. Note the logic (?): it would be easy &c. yet they can only be refuted by hard facts and statistics," and, moreover, must needs be handed over to the secretary who is used to dealing with these questions," and, therefore, I presume, paid for so dealing. Now, mark, learn, and inwardly digest," this was a foul blot on Mr. Smith in Mr. Valentin's way of thinking. Mr. Valentin's precipitate retreat reminds one forcibly of Paddy and his shield, and his delegating the work to some one more able than himself—to the school boy and his big brother. How Mr. Valentin quibbles. Even in the self- evident war between heaven and hell," he must needs add" places of which we know absolutely nothing "-ivhoever would have thought of two places, as such, at war ? Mr. Valentin knows as well as I do that reference is here made to two antsganistic forces good and evil." Mr. Valentin now deals in the metaphysical—and apparently is at home—and can say what he pleases without fear of refuta- tion, but still he should speak for himself. Perhaps, some of the Llanelly theologians can enlighten him on the subject. But now comes the unkindest cut of all." He says:—Mr. Williams has "adopted the well-worn tactics of professional teetotalers in suppressing important words in my letter and suggesting false ones to make them suit his arguments." Now this statement, to put it in the mildest form, is as false as it is mean. The whole letter is, in fact, a glaring instance of literary juggling and false repre- sentation from beginning to end. Where have I suppressed? What have I suggested? Will Mr. Valentin do me the justice to mention the words so treated ? The sentence he refers to was my own and was thisthat medical men did not now advocate the indiscriminate use of alcohol even in moderation." Now Mr. Valentin has misconceived, and consequently miscon- strued the above simple sentence which will be self evident and intelligible even to a standard III board school boy. This of itself evidently proves that Mr. Valentin his quite incapable of discussing the question at issue and has wisely delegated the work to abler hands under the week-kneed plea of no time, and moreover that Mr. Valentin had needs consult an elementary grammar as well as a shilling dictionary. If he thinks he has the better of the argument by getting off the main issue at every possible chance he is welcome to think so, but it by no means proves that he has a superabundant supply of that commodity he is so fond of refer- ring to-com mom sense, which he asserts the "so-called temperance party" is deficient in. For a specimen of "Billinsgate," pure and unadulterated, and trade manufactured, allow me to refer to you, Mr. Valentin, to the Llanelly Railway Station as reported in last Thursday's 1?'e?y. "The defendants were drunk and disorderly and using very dirty and abusive language." The Bench said "the conduct of the defendants on this occasion was coriduct of the eteferj,,I atits oil this occasion was my epithet filthy offspring." A few words re Mr. P. C. Morgan's letter. Mr. Morgan's intervention is somewhat fortun- ate, but it does not seem to over-credit Mr. Valentin's ability to sustain the attacks of his opponent. Will Mr. Morgan kindly read my statements over carefully before rushing into print and also read Mr. Valentin's original letter, then he will be better able to discriminate what I mean and it will save repetition. First, I never produced the ipse dixit of several individuals as proof. I do not quote from a brewer's pamphlet in support of temper- ance. I am ready and willing to discuss the whole economic aspect of the drink question with Mr. Morgan. I never said that the whole legal paraphernalia cost £ 150,000,100 and consequently could not have added a cypher thereto. Will Mr. Morgan kindly refrain from imputing motives. He says I use the word aleo/wl in the present instance in order to mislead. Let him remember the proverb, "JIal y soit qui mal y pense." This proves that either Mr. Morgan has not compared my reply with Mr. Valentin's letter or he has misunderstood itintentionally or not I cannot say. Finally, the statement made by Mr. Valentin was the increase of drunkenness in shebeens &c., the stock arguments of Anti- Sunday Closing-ites. With the latter I shall deal at greater length again, with the editors kind permission. I remain, yours, £ c., JO U-N H. WILLIAMS. London Hospital, London. E.

A FIRE AT THE LLANELLY RAILWAY…

MILL LANE MISSION ROOM.

A BRILLIANT METEOR

Advertising