Welsh Newspapers

Search 15 million Welsh newspaper articles

Hide Articles List

42 articles on this Page

FOOTBALL LAW AMENDMENT.I

News
Cite
Share

FOOTBALL LAW AMENDMENT. I SOME LAST WORDS. I was almost afraid of being shut out. On Saturday more and the Express" Editor would have sniffed at the above title as a preliminary to labo- riously guiding his fingers through his hair and pouching his lips for passwords —which is a. way he has when he thinks I things don't fit in for the public good. But before the football curtain is quite down, while yet we can see a few flicker- ing feet on the stage, likely laws are pushed in for the consideration of Express" readers. The fag end of a season, in which quite a number of laws have benefited from; addition, deletion, or fuller explanation, may, perhaps, be considered as hardly the time for thoughts of laws not yet made; but, when it is considered that the four months of coming rest give excellent thinking time, free from the worry of the cry of the victor and the sob of the slain, then the following will be agreed upon as not only not nearly out of season, bat distinctly and gether in it. The likely laws that are touched upcn will be found of greater interest from the fact that they are either suggestions from down under— the land of the All Blacks—or are from the land of their footbally-very-dear (if not very near) neighbours, Australia. The furore created by the New Zea- iaoders and the effect of their visit will make Season 190-5-6 ever be remembered as the New Zo-lindcrs' season. Every- thing pertaining to thpir gmc has be;n j 'e-rsjit. j»nd. ?though likely i .r; t 1.£.14 J.. 't;J I to fL.:i.h up with, 'idcncing the .i.l or CoiOiiii-.i opinion as to wnat the game needs in rules for its fuller deve- lopment, should not fail to interest. So much for introduction. Now, as the immortal Tom says. Let's get on with the work." v The New Zealand, the New South Wales, and the Queensland Rugby Unions, the governing bodies of down below, are net all of the same mind with regard to this suggested amendment sent for the consideration of the English Union, for, while New South Wales would allow a goal to be obtained from a punt as well as from a drop-kick and place-kick, the other two Unions dis- agreed—the one, New Zealand, because the number of points given for a goal would be too many to fit the value of a punted goal, and Queensland because she did not ?gree with a punted goal at all, whatever the points granted. Perhaps it will be considered hasty work to hea<! the punted goal amendment as Likely Law. But why not ? I allow that it may be seasons to come before the change takes place, but, with a decreased number of points—say, two points for a punted goal—I see no reason why such goal should not be allowed. Punting as an art is more easily acquired than drop or place kicking, it ii true; but anyone that has an idea that punted goals would be quite too numerous would lay himself open to much surprise. The punt is more often used than the drop, rather from the fact that a more quickly-rising punted ball is less liable to be charged down. There is also greater certainty in taking a punt than in taking a drop-kick when the ball is at ail inclined to pointedness at the ends. But. allowing all that, some credit should be given for the clever punting which lands the ball over the bar, even though that credit be in the direction of but half the value of the goal obtained by the cleverer drop-kick. As is well known, drops-out are now taken from the kicker's 25. and are taken after a touch down, touch-m-goal. dead ball, and an unsuccessful kick at goal from a try. Thera are cases in which a touch down, by reason of the ball being kicked off from the 25, gives the defend- ing side too great an advantage. They are able to ease the strain of a strenuous attack by means of a touch down, which may have been ail-but a try. In such cases the down-unders say that the drop-out should 00 from behind the goal- line, a.nd that the opponents should stand ten yards away and be quiet there. To of the three Colonial Unions sta.nd exactly in line on this amendment; Queensland doesn't completely agree. She thinks that where an attacking side is foolish enough to kick a dead ball the present rule is good enough for them then. Otherwise she agrees. I hardly think this amendment is fair in the case of a try being obtained. These points have I rewarded the attack, and the shorn side should be given a satisfactory re-start from the 25. With this change the pro- posed amendment and the likely law would read to state that, except after an unsuccessful goal-kick following a try, and also except after a dead ball kicked by an attacking player, the drop-out should be taken from behind the goal- line, opposing players to stand ten yards away and not to charge, the procedure after the unsuccessful try at goal and the dead-ball kick to be as in the present rules. The Colonial amendments :ivj tir: r. the -.ling, but as of making rh:* ut. -uo quicker and brighter they would go far. The touch, down, when the drop-out has to be taken from behind the goal-line, is likely to be avoided. Play will thus be kept going. In connection with drops-out the Colonists have a strong combined belief that the delay from drops-out falling into touch should be done away with. There) is nothing more annoying than to see the ball on being kicked pitching into touch, several times, to the great waste of the football-playing time. It is evident that such a proceeding has annoyed folks below, for they ask an amendment in the direction of alio*, ing the game to go on as though it had been kicked into touch in the ordinary way. This amendment, if adopted, would get the ball into play at once. I should be inclined to suggest, that it the ball were kicked to pitch into touch that it be scrimmaged on the 25 j yards line. Ir mis were the rule we I should have little trouble with the kick- ing into touch from the drop-out. The Colonial amendments certainly run in the right direction for the bettering of this law. and the sooner the amendments are adopted the better for the game. The definition of "scrimmage," helped with a couple of notes, is in this season's hand-book quite helpful. "What is. a scrimmage ?" and "When is a scrimmage a scrimmage and when isn't it?" were common enough questions prior to this season. It has taken happenings and given much worry to get a satisfactory answer to these. Again, in this. too, the Cblonists have experienced similar expe- riences to ours. This can be gauged from the following, which are part of what they desire inserted under the law relating to scrimmage, and upon the neoessity for which they were in complete unanimity: A scrimmage ceaees to exist when the ball touches or crosses the goal-line. The ball should not be played in any manner in a scrimmage by the hand or arm. The ball must be put into a scrimmage in such a way that each side shall have an equal opportunity of obtaining possession of it. No player is offside while he remains part of a scrimmage and the ball is therein. The fide not committing the breach shall have the right to put the ball in the scrimmage. The ball shall be put in any side the referee may direct. These suggested insertions are direct and to the point, and cover a great deal. of the ground left unexplained by the scrimmage definition, and even accepted decisions of previous seasons. It would do much good if they were included now. Their directness is very satisfying.

Advertising

RUGBY. I

ASERAVON. I

ABERCANAID._-I

ABEROARE. I

Advertising

I ABERTILLERY._

CWMBRAN. I

CRUMLIN. - !

--MOUNTAIN ASH..I

NEATH. I

PONTYPRIDD. I

I TROEDYRHIW. i

I-TREORKY._---I

ISOCCER GOSSI P.I

ITON-PENTRE. -I

IMARK TWAIN ON GOLF.I

IBASEBALL NOTES.

II I CARDIFF HARRIER FOR CANADA.…

I LEADERS -OF SPORT.

IPERCY WILLIAMS, Nelson. !

E. OLIVER, Ogmore Vale School.…

REES PHILLIPS, Briton Ferry.

Dr. J. R. ARMSTRONG I

Advertising

I -NEWBRIDGE.

I -PLYMOUTH (MERTHYR).

==-=-.--I IGLOUCESTER'S BRILLIANT…

I CLUB RECORDS. '-"'"-

.LLANELLY. I

CWMPARK. I

CWMBRAN. 1

I PENYLAN.-7-

PENYORAIG.

SWANSEA SECOND XV.

TROEDYRHIW.

MORE CRICKET GOSSIP.

BEDWAS.

CWMBRAN.

GLAMORGAN LEAGUE.

-SWANSEA.