Welsh Newspapers

Search 15 million Welsh newspaper articles

Hide Articles List

10 articles on this Page

ST. DAVID'S SCHOOL SITE.

News
Cite
Share

ST. DAVID'S SCHOOL SITE. CORPORATION WISH TO ACQUIRE IT. PROPOSED EXTENSION OF MUNICIPAL OFFICES. WHY THE RECTOR AND CHURCHWARDENS OBJECT. ,m Tuesday morning, Mr. M. K. North, M. Inst. C.E., held an inquiry at the Town Hall relative to the petition of the Corpora- tion to the Local Government Board to issue a Provisional Order to empower the Council to put in force the powers of the Lands Clauses Act with respect to the purchase and taking of lands otherwise than by agreement, with refer- ence to certain lands forming part of the site of the old St. David's National School, and re- quired as a site for the erection of public offices, and also for sanction to borrow 2650 for purpose of sewerage for the village of Pen- garnddu. Those present included the layol (Coun. F. T. James). Town Clerk (Mr. T. Aneuryn Reee), Coun. F. S. Simons, Dan Thomas, W. Lewis (Penydarren), and H. M. Lloyd, Dr. Duncan (M.O.H,), Mr. W. R. Harris (Borough Con- troller), Mr. A. Marshall (assistant Surveyor), and Chief Constable Wilson. The Rector of Merthyr (Rev. Daniel Lewis) attended to op- pose the application respecting St. David's School site, accompanied by his churchwardens and a number of sidesmen The Borough Controller having given the usual figures relating to the population, rate- able value, etc., the Rector of Merthyr asked him why he did not state the amount of water rate.—Mr. Harris: There is no water rate The Rector then requested that a plan pre- pared and submitted to Parliament, and signed by three parties, the Borough Council, Sir Wm. T. Lewis, and himself, should be produc- ed. That plan, he said, showed how the Coun- cil intended to erect public buildings on the Castle Field. The Town Clerk: Plans were never present- ed to Parliament. Rector: Excuse me. I am very sorry to go irito this matter. But it is of supreme impor- tance that this plan hereafter should be re- fc rod to. The Inspector: The Town Clerk says he will get all the plans he has. The Rector: Showing the proposed build- j Town Clerk: There is no such plan. He then explained that the reason of this application jv-s because the Corporation were very short of room. The Town Hall bad only been erected t<>urteen years, but since then the Local Board of Health had given place to a Corporation, And now Merthyr had been created a County Borough, and a quarter sessions borough, with control of police. They had had to provide accommodation for the Education Authority's staff, and also for the work formerly carried out by the Burial Board. Police accommodation was also needed, also a magistrates and justices' clerks' rooms. The Town Hall was totally in- adequate for the requirements of the Cor- poration and Education Authority. The St. David's School site was the most suitable one. as it adjoined the Town Hall. The Council had the option of purchasing a site at the rear of the Castle Hotel for £5,000, but the Inspec- tor would agree with him that it was not such a convenient site as the one proposed to be acquired. MORE ACCOMMODATION ABSOLUTELY NECESSARY. The Mayor said the work of the Corporation could not be properly carried on, and some time ago the Council had to erect a. corrugated iron building alonside the Town Hall as an educa- tion office. Even the old School Board contem- plated erecting a separate building; at that time he was solicitor to the School Board. The education requirements were increasing very rapidly. Last year the Council had to appoint several new officers, including inspector of school children, a female inspector of midwivea, etc., who had no accommodation at the Town Hall. An organiser of education had now to be appointed. Then the accommodation at the police station was totally inadequate. The six cells were overcrowded, as very often 22 per- sons were locked up from. Saturday till Mon- day. Then a children's court had to be provid- ed, and now the Council had to appoint a cor- oner and give him a court. Many other rooms were rewired, and the County Council had threatened to cease paying rental if the Council did not provide accommodation for the county magistrates. Plans had been prepared showing how the proposed site would be laid out. It was proposed to transfer the whole of the con- troller's staff into the new building on the first floor. It was proposed to connect the two build- ings by a-toridge. The education department would occupy the ground floor, and also the or- ganiser of schools, the medical officer, weights and measures, and so on. Even then only sufficient accommodation would be left in the Town Hall for the requirements of the Corpor- ation. The Mayor then said that for the last three years the St. David's School site had been an eye-sore to the town. If the site had been properly utilised by the Rector and church- wardens, when the schools were condemned by the Board of Education one would have had some compunction in taking this step. But the original uses for which that site was. grant- ed by the owner of the freehold had not been carried out. There was no school there now. Rector That is not correct. The Mayor: I say what I conceive to be the present position. The present site, he said, had remained unutilised in its present condition for three years, from the date the children were re- moved from the schools, and had to bo pro- vided with accommodation by the Corporation in various chapels and vestries in the town. The local authority had been pressed. by the Board of Education, and the grant threatened, because they had not built new schools to provide for the children in the town district. But land had been taken, and that accommoda- tion would now be provided. If the Corpora- tion obtained the order market value would be paid for the site. The Council said it was an absolute necessity that the Town Hall should be oxtended in order that the work of the County Borough should be properly and efficiently car- ried out, and the Council were unanimous in coming to that conclusion. The Castle Field was II; most unsuitable site upon which to erect public offices. It was shut in by a row of small houses, with the backs looking on to the field, and on the other side was the Morlais Brook, a very unpleasant stream to live near. It was in the interests of the inhabitants that the Corporation sought to acquire this site. The Inspector: There is no other site you could purchase by agreement on the other three sides of the Town Hall?—The Mayor: No; we are, really driven to get this site; It was thought, he said, that the Castle Field would have been a good site for a secondary school, but since then the Council had purchas- ed Cyfarthfa Castle, which they proposed to use as a school, and plans had been provisionally approved by the Board of Education architect. So'that the need of Castle Field, so far as edu- cation was concerned, had gone. Since the no- tice was given with regard to this Provisional Order he had met all classes of ratepayers and inhabitants, and with few exceptions, they ap- proved of what the Corporation proposed to do. THE CASTLE FIELD SITE. The Rector again asked for the plan show- ing the public buildings the Corporation were going to erect on Castle Field. The Town Clerk said that there was no such plan in existence; it must exist in the Rector's imagination. The Rector: If the Surveyor was here he would bear me out. It is suppressed for an object, I submit. Did you ever see a plan showing the position of the buildings to be placed on the Castle Field?-The Mayor said a plan was prepared showing how the site was to be 'utilised, including, ho believed, law courts, free library, fire station, and baths. Rector: It is important to get that fact ad- mitted. The Town Clerk denied it. i The Mayor said the Council had' not with- drawn their proposal to purchase the Castle Field. The Act of Parliament giving them that Field. The Act of Parliament giving them that power would last up to August next year. The Rector said the ex-Mayor Btated before the last Commissioner that the Council did not intend going on with the Castle Field. The Mayor: That was his own personal opinion. There is no resolution binding the Corporation to throw up their important powera j as to the Castle Field. Perhaps the Council will require the site upon which to build work- men's dwellings, t I The Rector: Are you not aware that the Commissioner asked that very important ques- tion before the loan for the purchase of Cy- farth Castle was granted? The Mayor: The Commissioner did ask it, and I say that the Mayor was wrong in saying that the Corporation had decided not to pur- chase the site. Rector: You have the agreement. Are you aware that I was not consulted in the slighter degree as to the option to purchase which was incorporated into the Act of Parliament? Mayor: I have no knowledsre of it. I can only deal with the Act. of Parliament as it is b.for me. Rector: Have you heard it?—Mayor: i. un- derstand from the Town Clerk that you now express your surprise at the provisions in the Act, but here they are. That is your own fault. You could have employed your own agents or solicitors. The Inspector: It's no good crying over spilt milk. Rector: Do you think the buying of this piece of land will be more economical than the J.istlo Field?—The Mayor: Yes. Rector: Supposing it is quite the contrary? --Mayor: It is only hypothetical. By the time an approach road was made to the Castle Field, it would cost £ 6,000, before we put a stone on any building. If you want a site for church or educational purposes you have ample ground to build upon at the back of Victoria- street or on the Castle Field itself, where there are a lot of insanitary cottages which you could pull down and re-build, Rector: Then you think economy affects the Council and not the Church party?—Mayor: I say to the ratepayers, whatever creed they are Rector: One of the chief things is conve- nience and economy with you ?—Mayor: Yes. Don't you think that convenience and ecoiv oniv to rhe owners is of very great importance? C'ndoubtedly. Have you known at all about the unanimous opinion about this matter?—The Corporation are unanimous. The resolution was passed unanimously, and every member had & statu- tory notice to attend the meeting. It is incorrect if some differ from you?—I can only speak as to what I saw and the re- cords of the Corporation. NO ESTIMATE YET PREPARED. Have you any idea as to the amount of money required to carry out this scheme?—No. The Engineer has not submitted an estimate. You are aware that the Borough of Merthyr is burdened already?- Y es, but it is under Cor- porations of similar size. It is about JE6 a head. How much do you think the Corporation would want to carry out all the improvement* contemplated?—I could not say The Rector: It is an unknown factor. He then questioned the Mayor with regard to PoiH- morlais improvements, the widening of High- street, Pontmorlais, but the Mayor replied that there was no compulsion to go on with those works in any given time. The Rector: Are you aware that we with- drew our opposition to the Bill in the House of Commons because of the "urgency" of these matters?—The Mayor replied that Pontmorlais improvement was in hand, and so was Cefn Bridge. The Inspector told the Rector that he was going a long way from the St. David's Schoo! site. The Rector: Are you the initiator of this?— The Mayor: I gave notice of motion. I felt that the work of this Corporation could not be properly carried out without further offices. You thought to mark your year of office by doing something? (laughter).—That was not my object. The Town Clerk said that earlier in the day he understood the Rector to say that a plan was submitted to Par!iament. A block plan was prepared, but not submitted. Rector: The Mayor has admitted he saw the plan. The Inspector: But it was never submitted to Parliament. In reply to the Town Clerk, the R-sctor ad- mitted that he had received notice that the Corporation were going on with the widening of Lower High-street, but he had not seen the notices in the papers. "I don't read papers; I seldom have time to do so," added the Rec- tor. Town Clerk: How did you know about this inquiry, then? Chief Constable Wilson read a report which he laid before the Watch Committee in Sep- tember last, pointin- out the lack of police and fire brigade accommodation.—He was cross-ex- amined by the Rector as to the non-use of cot- tages in Albert-street, behind the police sta- tion, and said that the Corporation were oblig- ed to buy those premises from the County Council when they took over the police sta- tion. The cottages were not used because they were dilapidated. INSPECTOR AND CONDITION OF ST. DAVID'S SCHOOLS. Mr. A. Marshall, assistant surveyor, then I explained ttie plans snowing now the St. Da- vid's School site would be utilised. The area-, j he said, wad 1,470 sq. yards, but 700 sq. yards j would not be touched by the Corporation, which might be utilised for church purposes. The Inspector: These schools are in a ruin- J ous condition?—Mr. Marshall: They are very dilapidated. The Rector said the schools had not ceased to be used. The Town Clerk said the schools were not in a fit state, and the Board of Education gave I the Rector and Managers ample time, over 18 months, to put the premises in a proper con- dition, but they refused to do so, and the Board struck the schools off the grant list. la consequence of that the Council had to provide accommodation for the children. The Inspector: It is no exaggeration to say that they are in a ruinous condition ?—Mr. i Marshall: Quite so. I Inspector: If the Local Government Board issue this order I suppose it will be the in- tention of the Council to pull these schools issue this order I suppose it will be the in- tention of the Council to pull these schools down?—Mr. Marshall: We must do so to build I offices. The Inspector asked about the tenancy of the site.—The Town Clerk said it was vested in the Rector and Churchwardens under a trust deed for the purpose of maintaining schools for the education of the children of the poor of i the neighbourhood.—The Inspector: From az. architectural point of view there is no other l site which c«uld possibly be utilised?—Mr. Marshall: There is no vacant land any whfeis: nearer than the Castle Field. nearer than the Castle Field. The Rector: Where is Mr. Harvey to-day? f —Mr. Marshall: .He is giving his daughter away in holv matrimony (laughter1. Mr. Marshall denied that any p:an, except I a block plan, was made SDowinj: bow the Castle Field was proposed to be used. The Mayor: That is so. A block plan show- ing the area.. Rector: I shall give it in cvioence that there ing the area. Rector: I shall give it in evidence that there is a plan. This closed the case for the Corporation. I OBJECTIONS TO M.'IK SCHEME. The Rector then called L>r. W W. JOMS, churchwarden, and one oi trustees of the St. David's School site. He ^a.*o that the Ree- tor and churchwardens had been unable to use the land because of the action of the Cor- poration. They were prepared to begin the work at any tims—either to build schools or anything they were allowed to. If trust failed the land Would revert to the original owjier, the Rector of the parish. The Inspector: Haven t you been rather afraid of losing jt? (laughter).—Dr. Jones re- plied that the Board closed the schools. TJje premises had, however, been used for paro- J chial meetings. I The Town Clerk: «hy •didn't-you execute the repairs the Board of Education asked you to do?—We wanted to rebuild, and not re- Paif- Why didn't you ?—^Ve did not start with des- patch, And repeated that the Board of Educa- tion closed the premises. The Town Clerk asked Dr. Jones a. question about the trust, when the Rector interrupted with the remark: "The question of the trust does not arise in this case at all." The Inspector: I have allowed you a great deal of latitude. You must give and take. The Town Clerk: The trust is not at an end yet, when it is the land will revert to the original owner of the ground, and that is not the Rector of Merthyr?—Witness: There we join issues. Dr. Jones also said that the trustees had plans prepared and approved by the Board of Education and the Local Authority, but the work was stopped by the joint action of the authorities. Mr. T. Gunter. churchwarden of St. David's, said he attended on behalf of the congrega- tion to object to the proposal. It was propos- ed to erect a church institute on the site, as j such an institution was badly needed in Mer- thyr. The Inspector: To do so would be to act il- legally, would it not? The Rector: No; it would be approved, and be in keeping with the trust. The Town Clerk: Dr. Jones said the sugges- tion was to build a school. Witness: Dr. Jonei is churchwarden of the parish church. Town Clerk: There is a conflict of opinion as to what you would do with the ground (laughter). Ir Henry Owen, wine and spirit merchant, I said be protested against the trust being vio- I. lated or interfered with. The site was close to the church, and should be used for parochial purposes. The Rector was prepared to start with the building of the institute at once. In Wales, he said. Church schools and Church pro- pan.y had been harassed for some time, and ho suggested that if tbig site^ belonged to any sect except the Church of England the Cor- poration would not seek to acquire it (laughter). That was his opinion, because the Council would not be unanimous. The Town Clerk: You know there are other sites belonging to the Glebe'Yes, I am look- ing to convenience Town Clerk: So are we. Is there a pressing ueed for an institute ?—NV itness I think so. Mr. Rice. merchant. Brecon-road, said he ob- jected to the proposal because land available for religious purposes H! the centre of the town was getting less and less. The Calvinistic Methodists ajid the Zoar Chapel had had to pur- chase land for church cxt^r.s:on; He suggested the buildiug of an insutuie twelve ai-nths ago. j "I quite ajrree," he added, 'That u ihe ground • is to be left as it is now that the Corporation j should take it" (heajr, Lear). 1 GLEBELAND RENTALS. Mr. Stream, a sidesman at St. David's, said that the late Col. Lewis had spoken about the re-erection of the schools, and also the building of a church hall. It would cost the trustees a lot of money to find a fresh site. Town Clerk: Have you any idea what the rental of the glebe is?—No. Town Clerk: It is over £ 3,000 a year. Hector: That does not arise. That is most untrue. The question does not arise, and I deny it emphatically. My agent is here. The Rector then said that the Church lost a valu- sble supporter in Col. Lewis. From the begin- ning difficulty had arisen, he said, through the hostility of the local authority born of his hostility to the Incorporation movement. He felt that the ratepayers were going to be eoover- burdened that a large number of people, he feared, woidd repudiate their obligations so far as the ownership of property was concerned, by the losing of leases. The Merthyr Council, from the beginning of the Act of 1906. militated against the welfare of St. David's Schools, try- ing to capture them by every means possible. They were the best attended schools, and he thought without exception the best conducte-1 schools in the town. A contract had been en tered into to rebuild the girls' school, partly re- build the infants' school, and renovate the boys' school. Plans were approved by the Dspan- ment and the Local Authority, the contract was entered into, and the work begun. The contract for the boys' school was finished, and it was now one of, if not the best. schools in town as far as fabric and appointments were concerned. The Inspector: This is off the site? The Rector: Yes. Proceeding, the rev. gen- tleman repeated that the trustees were harassed by the local authority, and he challenged them to produce copies of letters to the Board where- in the Board was constantly called upon to give notice that they would not maintain the school unless they had their own recommendations carried out. The work of rebuilding the girls' school was commenced when tho Managers were notified that the school would no longer be re- cognised. The builder suffered a good deal in consequence of the inclemency of the weather, and work had been delayed, but the ambitions of the local authority brought the matter to a crisis. He (the Rector) went to the Board of Education, but could not Pft any remedy. As had been said, great hostility had been shown to voluntary schools in Wales. He would not have entered into this matter but for the rea- son that it had been put forward that the trust had failed. The trust had not failed: it was still rroing on. He desired notice to be taken of this, that if the trust had failed the property j would have reverted to two owners, and both I of those owners had not been invited to ap- j pear at the inquiry. The Rector produced a j case heard in the High Court on November 16th I last. Attorney General v. Shadwell, showing that, the site would revert to the donors. It j was not, true that the buildings had ceased to be used for three years. The trustees had a desire, i and an intention, to proceed forthwith with ¡ the building of a church institute on the site. j and but for what had occurred the work would have been commenced. He strongly opposed ) this application on the ground, amongst others, that the site formerly formed a part of the srlebe, and was given by two rectors interested j in the emoluments of the parish, and it was j cpriainlv reasonable that the former owners and worshippers of the church should have their convenience and economy considered, as had been stated. To show the animus of the local authority, they were under the impression that they could capture the schools immediately they j were stopped, but in this they were somewhat sadly disappointed. He would put alongside of that the action of the local authority in draft- ) ing the children to chapels and vestries which did not comply with the regulations laid down in the Codn so far as accommodation and san- itary considerations were concerned. Both the Corporation and the Education Board had been ioint actors in this action, which was a surprise to the inhabitants generally. He would point out that the amount of money required for the purchase of this site would be very much Wore than the amount which had been agreed upon for the purchase of Castle Field. So that really the question of economy fell to the ground, and that was an important fact. The Rector again said that the plan for the laying out of i Castle Field was suopressed for a motive. í THE MAYOR'S PROTEST J The Mayor: I enter my protest against that i observation. Coun. F S. Simons: I protest, too. I carried through these negotiations with the Rector in London, and there is no such plan. The Injector: Please keep away from these very ooniToversial matters.. Rector: It is part and parcel of it. I should never have withdrawn my opposition to the Bill if I had known that. The Mayor: Castle Field site has nothing whatever to do with this inquiry. The Rector continued to attack the Corpor- I ation, and the Inspector said he must rule the i Rector out of order. He had allowed him lati- tude, but the rev. gentleman was going into all sorts of side issues relating to Castle Field. The Rector said the Council required £ 80,000 for education purposes. j Town Clerk: This is only wasting time. The Rector said he did not engage counsel, I but he thought be had a right to some con- sideration, because be had not been accustomed to these inquiries daughter). Inspector: Keep more particularly to the j point. We are wasting a lot of time. Rector: I submit they have acquired two J sites for pub-lo offices. The Inspector: That is not before me at I a-l. The Rector My piea is a. reason that they should not acci;i*c this site now. The au- thorities in po^T-ct.-ion of the site were prepared to ruake use of it immediately. The site was one d the most valuable in the town, being in tr. centre of the principal street, and he again emphasised the fact that the question of econ- omy which had been put forward fell to the '¡ ground. He contended that the Corporation's requirements could be met by building offices on the north Bide of the Town Hall, the other side of tho ttam-road, and a bridge across the tramway could be made. He, therefore, on be- half of a very large number of people, asked that the application be not granted. The Mayor said he protested against the statement of the Rector that the inafnts' and girls' schools were abandoned chiefly in conse- quence of the action of the local authority aad the Board of Education. The Education Com- miitee would have, been only too delighted had the Rector carried out the proposals to rebuild the schools. It would have saved the ratepayers a. large sum of money. He understood from the late Co!. Lewis that the contract to rebuild was never signed. The lector denied this, and said that Mr. Jenkins, buLiJer, had the contract. The Tcm>. Clerk said the only plan prepared re Castle F>e! was a block plan, produoed to- day. *W" regard to the Rector's rambling statement e.'iotii the opposition of the local authority ;oiotly with the Board of Education, that was met" nonsense. A Government De- partment wouid not join with any public body in harassing ? Church of England School. Rector- They did 8fv Town Clerk: I absolutely deny it. The Rector: The harassing can be seen by the letters in the Council office. Secondly, as a proof of the harassing our teachers were riot paid the same salaries as tho teachers in the Council Schools, and the salaries of our teach- ers when transferred to Council Schools were immediately increased—a monstrous shame. The Inspector: I have inspected this site— and took the opportunity of viewing the church at the same time (laughter). The inquiry then closed.

[No title]

Advertising

Advertising

Wonders of Your Skin.

Advertising

I Comets and Eclipses.

Advertising

! Mr. Edgar R. Jones, M.PA

. The Welsh Summer School.