Welsh Newspapers

Search 15 million Welsh newspaper articles

Hide Articles List

17 articles on this Page

Llandovery Petty Sessions.

News
Cite
Share

Llandovery Petty Sessions. Friday, before the Mayor (Councillor J. • Rees, Gloucester Hous), Alderman C. P. Lewis, Llandingat, and Mr. James R Tmh. TaigLocking A FILLY'S TAIL. IMPORTANT TO FARMERS. Tim court was crowded with the far and others interested in horeea. Th«^ttraction was a horse docking cam. iWd Ijloyd, Dolgarreg lorge, SStmV %ed wjth cruel!, £ its tail. Davies, the all- sista-ut, and John Divies, farmer, Penlan »>rn>, were Jones Llandovery, ^u"d, Mr T PhimPB,defendedM emphwzed a8 his main contention, the point ,by qua rf, •„ as the point upon which tfeRlP.Ci, wished to have the. de- "fl^nfteLed «at he passed Dol- e&rr«r Forge on tie 26tli of last month about ? n m When he came close to the forge, he noticed the defendant Lloyd doing some- Ur.. nn tn I thii* to the tail or a ini»re. the door of the smithy, and there saw blood ooming from the lower half of the door which half was shut. Defendant had hold ef the horse's tail, and was tying a string round it to stop the blading near the cut. Witness said to him Have you cut the horse's tail off?" He said Yes," and added What about that is it wrong." Witness replied "Yes, it is a case of cruelty. De- fendant returned I didn t know that. Behind the door the floor was covered with blood, and had the appearance of a slaughter house. The blood was running from the tail like a tap, and he (defendant) had very great difficulty in stopping it. Whilst, witness was tbore the animal seemed to be in grent pain. The ekin was creeking and the horse was shivering. The horse commenced kicking and jumping, and it took two men to hold it. The boy William, servant to Mr. Davies, Penian, was holding the animal by rho halter. Defendant Lloyd informed witness that Mr. Davies, Penlan was the owner, and that he had sent it there to be docked and shod. The owner was not present. Witness found the part of the tail cut off on the hearthst-one near the fire place. Lloyd ad- mitted that it was the part, ofthe tail cut off. Witness took possession of it. The assistant blacksmith was in the shop, but witness did not see him do anything. The assistant made a certain statement on the following day. Cross-examined: There was no attempt at cnnoealment on the part of defendants. No obstruction was put in my way. I have had experience of horses. I worked horses in my younger days. That was the first time I saw a horse being docked. I have studied the legal points of docking in the Society's fccoks. I nave read no farrier's book. Mr. Phillips: There are No convictions put forward by the Society (referring to yellow book produced)? There is no mention of a dismissal there. Cross-examination continued I still waintain that the blood was flowing as from a tap. I was in the shop about ten minutes. Mr. Phillips: If it ran like a street tap it weuld drain every drop of blood in the animal in tenminutes. Ald. Lewis: There are taps of different sizes. Mr. Phillips: When a tap is mentioned, my poimb is that Sergt. Deans is exaggerat- ing what he saw. Was any act of cruelty done whilst you were there?—I did not see the severing of the tail. I have seen many horses docked and undocked. The majority were docked. Although it was a young horse my opin,ion is that it was jumping and kicking owing to the tail being tied. That no doubt was a necessary part of the operat- tion to stop the bleeding. Re-examined by Mr. Jones: I am not a Veterinary Surgeon so can't say what ap- pliances other than those used could be em- ployed. Mr. Phillips: Didn't you see a tornicator put round it? Mr. Jones: Yes, after the tail had been cut. It would be better if put on before it waa cut. Cross-examined: It is not within my know- ledge that an animal on being docked is u?utflly allowed to bleed. Insp. Wra. Bowyer, R.8.P.C.A., deposed to calling at Dolgarreg Forge on the 27th of January and seeing, Lloyd's assistant, Wm. Davies. He told him that any statement h made would be voluntary. He then made a statement to the effect that on the fnevious day a servant of Mr. Davies, Pen- an, brought a young mare about two years of age to be shod and also to be docked. And after shoeing the horse he held the tail while Dd. Llovd cut. These notes were signed in the presence of P.S. Deans. The tail Lloyd cut with a piece of scythe (whieh witness produced). The tail was placed on a piece of block, and the seythe was placed on it and then struck with a hammer or piece of iron. The parts were then tied with a piece of string. Davies then told witness in answer to a question that Lloyd had gone to Penlan whither he proceeded in compdny of P.S. Deans. Before leaving the forge, witness examined it. It had recently been washed out. On the door there was a large quan- tity of fresh blood, reaching from the top to the bottom of the lower part. Some por- tions of the bricks on the floor were stained with blood and there were also spots of blood on the wall. At Penlan he saw John Davies, owner of the horse. He told Mr. Davies who he was, that he had come,in reference to the ease, and that he could please himself as to whether he told him anything or not. Mr. Davies said, in reply, that he gave the order for the docking of the horse, and would ac- cept all responsibility. He then produced a young mare filly which was standing in the I stable. At his request he brought her out. He said she was rather wild and only partly broken in. She appeared rather wild and frightened. On examining the tail he found it had been recently docked. The lower portion of the tail was tied with a string. A portion of the bone of the tail was exposed. The flesh had the appearance of having been singed or scared. At this time David Lloyd came up. Witness then repeated the statement which Lloyd made to him, which was substantially the same as that made by his assistant. Davies. He said first that he was about 10 minutes at the operation, but afterwards, after Mr. Davies had said some- thing to him in Welsh, said about 5 minutes. At the close of the operation he put a piece of pig fat on the tail. It was, he said, the custom of the country to dock tails, and he had done so before. Cross-examined: The soythe used for cut- ting the tail had been placed apparently in biding, for it took the men some time to'find it. He gave me every information. He also showed me the block of wood. The bright portion of the scythe had rusted a little on account of the damp weather since he had it. But it was not clean and bright when he had it first nor had it been for years The part with the fresh rust could easily be seen. Had not seen a horse docked. He did not think it bled 10 minutes like a tap as Sergt. Deans said. He had had a little experience of horses. He understood from Mr. Davies that it was the custom to dock horses. Asked if he suggested it would take f) minutes to dock the mare, he replied that it probably would if the horse was rest- (JaiI^hter and applause). Aid Lewis: If I hear that noise again I ivi ^e. Court cleared. Mr. Phillips: I have nothing further to ask after that. Re-examined by Mr. Jones: The rust on every Dart of the scythe except where he in- dicated was very old. Defendant Lloyd: It wasn't. Mr. Jones: The question of rust ha no- thing to do with it. It is the kind of in- strument used, and whether, it is skilfully performed. Mr. Phillips submitted for the defence that the custom of docknig was common in MI districts in Wales, and the maioritv of English districts. It was justifiable If jt was for the benefit of mankind and rendered the animal more serviceable. Aid. Lewis: The King does not dock his horses. Mr. Jones: Manv cases have been decided where it hns 1"n1r1 t'l.-xt doeking doesn't render the anii ds serviceable for the use of mankind. At this stage Mr. Phifc lips objected to a yellow-covered book issued by the R.S.P.C.A. being put in. He proceeded to say that he was going to put m a certificate granted by the King when Prince of Wales to David Lloyd for the pur- pose of 0 i v Quotir, case of Lewis v. termer, lir Phillips aed that where reason- able care and skm was exercised, a person vac not guilty of cruelly illtreating abusing or torturing an animal, even if the opera- tion was useless. Mr. D. T. M. Jones said that he was not aeking the Bench to decide whether dock- ing vai legal or illegal. He was asking tkem to decide whether the docking was per- formed skilfully and with a proper instru- ment. He held that docking with the in- strument produced was cruel. Mr. Phillips: As long as reasonable care is used-- Aid. Lewis: Reasonable care and proper instrument. Mr. Phillips contended that the case he had quoted was on all fours with the pre- sent. one. Mr. Jones: Was a scythe used? Mr. Phillips: No. Mr. Jones: Then it is ridiculous to say that it is on all fours. "Still, I have no ob- jection to your putting it in. Aid. Lewis: It is for us to decide from the evidence whether reasonable care was taken. Mr.. Philnps: It is thw habit, and the cus- tom for an animal to be docked. It makes it more serviceable for the use of man. It becomes a necessary part of every farmer's work to see that it is carried out. He ] would call the man who would show that all reasonable precautions were taken that when the animal left tlto forge it did not bleed, and that in from 3 days to a week the animal was as well as it could be. The In- apector never complained that there was an unskilful operation. If he suspected, he should again have visited the mare two or three days subsequently. For the defence, Dd. Lloyd, farrier and blacksmith, said he was a certificated far- rier. He had won at 18 to 25 shoeing com- petitions, including the Bath and West of England, and the Royal. In 1900 he won the freedom of the Worshipful Company of Farriers, and received the freedom of the City of London. He had been for the past thirteen or fourteen years in the habit of docking horses, and it was the custom in Llanwrda and the neighbourhood. Before performing the operation he brightened the part he used of the scythe, and he always rubbed the rust off. He then described the operation. He left the mare to bleed for a while as she was suffering from some irrita- tion. He scared the end up with a pre- pared iron to close the artery. It was dry when the Inspector saw it on the foil wing day. He followed out the instructions which he saw in his book on farriery im- plicitly in performing the operation. He used his own judgment in the bleeding. It did not run like a tap. It might have run for 4 or 5 minutes, as the, arteries did flow. By the Bench Some wanted the animals to bleed. Others wanted them tied up at once. The four or five minutes would be fro mthe beginning. He went on the fol lowing day to Penlan to repair a horse machine, and not to see about the condition of the mare. Cross-examined He was a certified far- rier. That meant for shoeing. He was not a qualified veterinary surgeon. Now do your certificates authorie you to dock horses ?-No. Mr. D. T. M. Jones These certificates are useless as qualifications for docking. They show that for shoeing he is one of the best in the country. Cross-examination The iron was not to be red hot when used for searing, but dark red. He always tried to have a joint i. cut- ting a tail. The length depended on the owner. Could not swear he had a joint in this cace. He bled to suit the convenience of customers. Modern science was against bleeding. Mr. Jones You let it bleed profusely contrary to modern science because the owner wanted it ?—Yes he had a better knife ciian the one (produced). Whv didn't you use it ?—Reply not caught. Cross-examination continued There was a proper docking instrument, but you could d") it quicker with the one produced. Mr. Davies, Penlan, owner of the horse. snid that in his opinion the docking was skilfully done. He could not expect it to be better, and he had had considerable ex- perience in horses. The Inspector gave it as his opinion that there was nothing wrong with the tail. Cross-examined He told Lloyd to let the horse bleed on account of a little rash on the neck, and small lumps. The horse was now quite well. The Bench said they were quite deter- mined to dismiss the case.

Amman Valley School Managers

Llandyssul Races.

------------..-LLANDEBIE.

[ County Council Nominations.…

...,¡:¡ Welsh Education Revolt

St Davlll's Day at Carmarthen.

jTragic Death of Mr C. P.…

Education Expendituae at Carmarthen.

[No title]

I • - LLANCATHEN.

TRAPP, LLANDILO

Carmarthensire Fallen Heroes…

[No title]

[No title]

Family Notices

[No title]