Welsh Newspapers

Search 15 million Welsh newspaper articles

Hide Articles List

16 articles on this Page

WOMAN'S TERRIBLE DEATH.

News
Cite
Share

WOMAN'S TERRIBLE DEATH. CRY FOR HELP DISREGARDED. ASTOUNDING EVIDENCE. WITNESS CENSURED. A great sensation was caused in the Saun- dersfoot district last week by the discovery of the dead body of a woman, almost nude, in the yard attached to Moreton Farm, St. Issells. The discovery was made by Mr Cozens, the tenant of the farm, who found a woman's clothes in an adjoining field, and, following up the tracks across the road and into the farm- yard, found the body lying face downwards in several inches of mud. After washing some of the mud off the face he recognised the body as that of Mrs Esther Phillips, wife of Mr Evan Phillips, blacksmith, Saundersfoot. P.S. Thomas, of Saundersfoot, and Dr. Evans, Saundersfoot, were communicated with, and the body was placed in a shed on the farm, being shortly afterwards conveyed to deceased s home at Saundersfoot. Deceased, who was at times addicted to drink, was 45 years of age, and leaves no children. A coroner's inquiry into the circumstances attended the death was subsequently conducted at the Coffee Tavern, Saundersfoot, by Mr F. J. Allen, the deputy coroner, and the following jury :—Messrs. James Vaughan (foreman), Wil- liam Beddoe, John Jones, Evan P. Bennett, Thomas Morris, Harold L. Thomas, Benjamin Scourfield, James LI. Twigg, William Harries, William J. Graham, Stephen Sheldon, John Davies, and Thomas Owen. Police-Sergeant Thomas, Saundersfoot, acted as coroner's officer, assisted by P.C. Thomas. After the jury had viewed the body evidence was called. Evan Phillips, the husband of the deceased, stated that he was a blacksmith living at Chapel Road, Saundersfoot. Deceased was 45 years of age. On Sunday she came to him and said she did not feel very well and was going over to the doctor. It was then about eleven o'clock in the morning. She went out and came back with the bottle of medicine (produced) in her hand, and said the doctor had given her one dose and she was going to take another then. She took the dose as she said. She then said the doctor had told her to move about a little and she was going out to the fields, meaning to the land witness held. She went out. It was then between one and half-past one. He never saw her alive after that. She was addicted to drink. She had been previously attended by the doctor, but not within the last three months. She was subject to fits, the last one being about twelve months ago. On Saturday night she had a little drop, but he had seen her worse. It was not with his knowledge that she had got the drink he had no idea where she had got it. On Monday he was called up to Moreton Farm.. The Coroner said he was sure the jury would join with him in expressing their sympathy with the husband. William Cozens, of Moreton Farm, St. Issells, stated that on Monday, November 28th, he found the deceased about half-past seven o clock in the morning. She was in his farmyard, flat on her face. Her face was in a couple of inches of mud. She was quite dead. There was nothing on her except her chemise. It was a cold night. It had been raining the first of the night, but there was not much rain after ten o'clock. He found her clothes first in the field a good distance off. That aroused his suspi- cions and he traced her steps. He went and informed the police-sergeant. By the Foreman—The clothes were from 70 to 80 yards from the body. The Coroner-How were the clothes on the ground ? Were they arranged as if she had taken them off? Witness-They were rather scattered. Mrs Frances Childs, wife of John Childs, labourer, gave evidence that on Sunday about a quarter to nine o'clock at night she spoke to deceased. She talked rather thick and gave witness the impression that she was under the influence of drink. Witness only talked with deceased for about a minute. Deceased asked for the loan of a lantern. Witness asked who was talking to her, and she replied Mrs Phillips. That was how witness knew who she was. Witness gave deceased a candle and a box of matches, and deceased went away in the direc- tion of Moreton. She said she wanted the candle to cross a bridge. There was no bridge towards Moreton, but witness thought she wanted the light to cross the bridge on her way home. By Mr Beddoe-The candle and matches were found about 100 yards further on from witness's house in the direction of Moreton. Deceased must have dropped them there. Wit- ness also saw the stout bottle produced close by. She did not examine it at the time, but afterwards, and found it empty. There were two broken matches lying on the ground, but no struck matches. John Henry Edwards, collier, of East Williamston, said that at 11.35 p.m. on Sunday night he passed by Moreton farmyard and saw somebody or something there all white, but could not say what it was. The Coroner—Did you think it was a human being ? Wituess-I didn't know what it was. I came against it and said "Good night," and the person replied "Good night." The Coroner—What did you do then ? Witness-I kept on walking. The Coroner—What happened then ? Witness—After I went on 40 yards she shouted for help. The Coroner-What were the words she used, Help Help 1" Witness—Only "Help" once, "for she felt very bad." The Coroner-What did you do then ? Witness-I stopped a minute and thought. I didn't know what to do, so I kept on for my work. The Coroner-Work on Sunday night ? Witness—Yes. It was explained that witness was employed at Bonville's Court Colliery and was then on his way to work. The Coroner—The reason why you didn't go back was because you felt timid 1 Witness—Yes, sir. Mr Beddoe-Why didn't you call in at John Childs's house ? Witness—I didn't think anything about it. Mr Beddoe-You knew it was a human being ? Witness-Yes. Mr Beddoe—Didn't you think it was your duty to help a human being ? Witness-Yes, but I was on my way to work then. Mr Beddoe—Would it have mattered about halt- a day's work if you could have saved the life of a fellow being 1 Witness-I didn't think of that then.. Mr Beddoe-I think it was your duty to have seen who it was required help and to have helped them. Witness-It was at the dead hour of night. Mr Beddoe — You were passing houses. Cozen's house was close by, and Mrs Childs's house only a little way further on alongside the road. I wonder you didn't call in to see them. I never heard of a worse case than that, a human being asking for help and no notice being taken of it. Captain Graham—Did you think it was a ghost ? Witness—A ghost I thought it was. The Coroner In what position was the woman ? Witness—She was sitting down. The Coroner-Close by the house ? Witness—Yes. The Foreman—And you had your lamp? Witness-I had the lamp but no light. The Foreman—She spoke to you "Good night." Witness-Yes. The Foreman—And you afterwards heard her call" Help 1" Witness—Yes. The Coroner—You knew it wasn't a ghost when she said Help ?" Witness—Oh, yes; I knew then. The Coroner- I think you deserve to be censured for not going back. Police-Sergeant Thomas — Did she say, Come and help me up, I am very bad ?" Witness-She said, "Give me help, I feel bad." The Foreman remarked that there would have been some excuse for the witness's con- duct if there had been no house near, but, there being houses near, he thought it was his bounden duty to inform somebody there was need for help. In reply to Police-Sergeant Thomas, witness said it was just in front of the Moreton front door the woman was sitting down. It was very dark at the time, and witness could hardly see his hand. He Could see something white by the side of the road that was all he could see. He went on he did not run away, he walked. The Coroner remarked that if witness had turned back he would probably have been in time to rescue the woman and save her life. Witness stated, in reply to a juror, that he thought it was a woman by the voice. By Police-Sergeant Thomass—Witness was by himself there was no one with him at the time. The Coroner—The only reason why you did not go back and help her was that you were afraid ? Witness-Yes, sir. The Coroner-You knew somebody wanted help, but you didn't go ? Witness—I was sure there was somebody there. Mr Scourfield-Did you say anything at the pit when you went to work ? Witness—I did. Mr Scourfield—Did no one volunteer to go and see what it was, or didn't you ask any one to go ? Witness—No, sir. Captain Graham—Did you hear it said that other men had heard her groaning inside the hedge ? Witness-No, sir. Police-Sergeant Thomas—How far would you be from the woman when you passed her ? Witness-Three or four yards. The Coroner—You were absolutely careless. You didn't care a bit whether it was a human being or not. If you had gone back you would probably have saved her life. The Foreman thought the witness ought to be censured for his conduct. It would be a warning to others. The Coroner (to witness)—Oh, well, that will do. Dr W. C. Evans, Saunderafoot, stated that he was called to deceased on Monday morning, and when he saw her she was dead. He examined the body. The only external in- juries he found were scratches on both knees and on the right leg from the knee down. These might have been produced by falling on the ground. There were also some slight marks on her hands, caused, in all probability, by being on her hands and knees. There were signs indicating that she died of suffocation. Her face was blue, and her tongue was swollen and protruding against her teeth. The eyes wf/re suffused. He thought the cause of death was suffocation. Some time ago deceased used to visit him frequently at the surgery, but on the Sunday morning in question she was not at his place at all; in fact, he was away from home all day. He had attended the deceased for the effects of drink, but not recently. He did not give the deceased the medicine bottle produced; in fact, she had not had any medicine from him for some months. The Coroner (handing Dr. Evans the medi- cine bottle which was nearly full of a red liquid)—What is this, doctor ? Can you say ? Dr. Evans—From what I can judge, it is simply a few drops of Condy's Fluid and water. The Coroner-To your knowledge, did she ever have fits ? Dr. Evans—Some time ago she frequently had epileptic fits. The Coroner asked the doctor if it was likely that deceased fell down in an epileptic fit on her face in the mud and was suffocated. Dr. Evans replied that from the fact that the clothes were found a short way off from the body he should think deceased must have been delirious. She might have been suffering from delirium, tremens. People so affected did strange things. Mr Beddoe-If she had been in a fit would she have dragged herself round the house ? Dr. Evans-Hardly. In reply to the Foreman, Dr. Evans said deceased might possibly have been able to cry for help though in delirium. Death, in his opinion, was not caused by exposure the symptoms pointed to death by suffocation. The Coroner-How long do you think she had been dead, doctor ? Dr. Evans—The post-mortem rigidity was forming. I should say she was dead about twelve hours. I saw her about twelve o'clock. The Coroner, in summing up, said it was very unsatisfactory as regards the witness Edwards. If he had gone back in all probability he would have saved her life, but he didn't go, and he deserved a vote of censure at the jury's hands. As for the cause of death, there was no doubt it was suffocation, as the doctor had told them, and that suffocation occurred while she was suffering from delirium tremens. The jury, after a brief consideration, unani- mously returned a verdict of "Death from exposure," and they passed a vote of censure on the witness Edwards.

TENBY BUILDER'S

SPECIAL MEETING OF THE

TENBY POLICE COURT. ...

ROBBERY. .'1.

[No title]

YESTERDAY'S POLLING. ---

RESULT OF THE POLL.

EVE OF THE POLL AT TENBY.

MR, W. A. WOOD'S ELECTION…

MARK MASONRY.

PEMBROKE BOROUGHS ELECTION.—A…

TENBY HUNT WEEK.

RESIGNATION OF MR. E. T. BOYCE.

POLICE COURT PROCEEDINGS.

ITHE MAYOR'S CHRISTMAS FUND,…