Welsh Newspapers

Search 15 million Welsh newspaper articles

Hide Articles List

15 articles on this Page

Educational Notes and Comments.

News
Cite
Share

Educational Notes and Comments. REPLY TO "ALPHA." Sir,—This is my fourth letter in the present controversy, and I think I shall complete what I have to say in another two. In one of his let- ters "Alpha" charged me with run- ning away. In last week's 'Leader' he opens his epistle by referring to my rambling correspondence. Xow let me see whether there are any grounds for these charges, or whether they are the stock phrases he uses in every controversy, if in- deed he has ever before taken part in newspaper discussion. If he will read my letter in your issue of Aug. 23 he will find that I dealt exhaus- tively and fairly with various points raised in his letter of the 16th Aug. I asked him what he meant by say- ing that the "appearance and stand- ing of the teacher would be con- demned if he came before a class dressed as a miner, scavenger, or tinplater." I had no reply to this except a vague reference that I was "comparing teachers with scaven- gers, etc." It was he himself who started the comparison. I ask again what he means by that, and whether he bases a claim for Y,50 or C60 per year because he has to get an extra suit of clothes every 10 months in order to appear respectable in front of a class of children. That was one point. Another was regarding his statement that 5 hours work are sufficient for teachers. I asked why were they so indecently anxious, if that were so, to under- take outside duties 1 And the only answer I get is that "teachers gladly accept this to eke out their insuffi- cient salary." A third point I took was his re- mark that he might argue that teach- ers were only paid for 10 months, and consequently not paid for holidays. Evidently my calculations on this head have frightened him, for he now withdraws that statement and childishly remarks, in effect: I didn't say we were not paid for holi- days, but I could if I liked." Is this the attitude of a straight controversialist 1 Why. better be a ramjbler than a shuffler. Let us have it one way or the other. Are teach- ers paid for 12 months including 2 months holidays, or are they simply paid for 10 months, with the two months holidays not paid for 1 This is a straight question, so let me have a straight answer it will be a useful exercise for him. "Teachers have to eke out their insufficient salary." By which he means, I suppose, that they could not pay their way on their ordinary salary but must, like many a poor collier's wife who gets 25s. a week, do a little char work so as to make both ends meet. I hope for the sake of his intelligence, though his hon- esty has got to be sacrificed. that he knows better than this. Glance around you, "Alpha." and let me know next week whether it is not men and women who are earning from 92 to 94 a week who are per- forming most of the spare time jobs. I know them, and could relate a few interesting facts if I thought the edi- tor would pass them. But enough on this head. After all why did I enter into this controversy and why do I criticise the teachers and the work they do, when I am told that I am an out- sider. lacking sympathy with the teacher's lot? Alas, I am. If I were a teacher my sympathies would probably lie with my class. In a struggle between a wolf and a lamb my sympathies are with the lamb, but if I were a hungry and rapacious wolf, my sympathies then would be with my "class." One would fancy that independent criticism was al- ways the best criticism, but "Alpha" has been taught to think differently. Still, I must not under-estimate his generosity, for in one place he has shown an unselfish spirit quite for- eign to his profession. I remember in Mountain Ash on one occasion, when the agitation for a miners' 8 hours day was on, a head-teacher found fault with the miners for seek- ing a reduction of hours. But not so "Alpha." In his last letter he writes: "When colliers will be work- ing 5 hours a day-and I see no reason why they should not aim at it —no more will be heard of the teach- ers' short working hours. Believe me. they are long enough." Well, now, this is marvellous, and I must send it on to Mr. D. A. Thomas. Very soon we shall see in large type

MINERS' NEXT STEP.

ITEMS OF INTEREST.

Quoits.

Farmer Boys Who Became Merchant…

Advertising

Merthyr Board of Guardians.

Cottage Homes Struck by Lightning.

Not Entertained.

Dr. Biddle's Resignation.

Relief and Compensation.

Local Government Board Orders.

Notices of Motion.

----Aberdare Interviews.

My Annual Tramp.