Welsh Newspapers

Search 15 million Welsh newspaper articles

Hide Articles List

10 articles on this Page

"""IiI-----q-T DRINKING AND…

News
Cite
Share

"IiI -q- T DRINKING AND DRUNKENNESS. Advocacy of the Extended Use of Alcohol. oWEEPING ASSERTIONS BY A DOCTOR. The foliowing letter to the Times, from the ¡.en of Dr. J. Morsimar Granville, will be read with considerable interest "Drunkenness is in no other sense the conse- quence of drinking than the destruction of a house by fire is the consequence of having a cooking range on the premises. This mode of reasoning, with the obvious rejoinder, is so obviously absurd that in no other connection than the 'teetotal' would it ba for one instant tolerated. It is not to engago in the puerile play of words with Sir W. Lawson and the advocates of what I believe to be one of the weakest and most mischievous crazes of the nineteenth century—I mean teetotalism- that I ask you to give me space in your columns, but because I think the time has arrived when it is desirable that someone who has strong views on the subject of what it is the fashion of the day to denounce as 'drinking' should speak out honestly. INCALCULABLE RAmI DONE BY THE SPREAD OF XJ-ETOTALISM. "I am perfectly well aware (continues Dr. Granville) that in professing a strong belief that abstinence from the use of wine and beer is a worse evil than the occasional abuse of these in- Loxicaiits-I use this form of expression advisedly ¡ —I am placing myself in antagonism to the majo- rity of medical wdterd on this topic; but I am so thoroughly convinced of the accuracy of my view, after forty years' study and observation of the subject in its piofessional and social asprcts, that I should be lacking in moral courage if I hesitated to express myself decidedly. I sincerely b.lieve that incalculable harm has been done to the average human organism, with its functions, which we are wont to classify as mental and physical, by the spread of teetotal views and prac- tices. There is less stamina in the life of the average Englishman now than there was 40 years ago. He may live a little longer, but he is not so well ible to resist the invading germs of disease or to recover from the debilitating effecis of such an invasion as he was when good wine ¡ and sonud al, formed integral parts oi his daily diet." DRINK AND INSANITY. Dr. Granville contends that "lÚink" has no appreciable relation tu the increase of insanity. Those who allege that the increase of insanity is due to drink forget that it in since the habit, of drinking has been reduced—a3 teetotalers allege -that insmity ha) increased, if, indeed, it has really increased. "I doubt whether, of the great bulk cf the eeneral practitioners who have opportunities of collecting information on this subject, any large number could compile twenty cases, falling under their individual observation, of pt r-ons who habitually drank freely and because insane. It is nothing to the point to tell us that of insane persons many once drank. What we want to know is the proportion of persons who I drirk parsing into the class of lunatics. So far as I have been able to asceriain, this proportion is so small as to be insignificant." CONSUMPTION AND CANCEB FIOURISII Ul"U£¡¡; A TEETOTAL REGIME. Meanwhile (Dr. Granville goes on to siy) a c-llm and careful survey of the statistical and clinical facts will show that not a few terrible diseases, such a consumption, cancer, specific maladies of low typn—for example, diphtheria, the worst forms of gout, nerve troubles, and a host of minor aiimenta having for their proximate, if not ultimate, causes those depressed and asthenic conditions of vital force in the organism which render it, as A whole, weak in the presence of its enemies, and, as to its constituent partf, prone to the degradation of organic type. of life-liave developed and extended their ravages since the practice of substituting" table waters" and watery wines for cound-rnalt and hop and grape—fermented beverages ha* sprung into fashion at the instance of the temperance advo- cates. These are grave assertions to make, and I am not insensible to the responsibility which attaches to a physician daring to n,ake them, but I I am persuaded that the time has come when those who do not share the views it is fashionable to pro- fess ought to declare themselves. TBETOTALISM DESTRUCTIVE OF MORAL, MENTAI, AND PHYSICAL HEALTH. Dr. Grnnville concludes his remarkable letter with the following statements This fanatical crusade against ti,e drinking of fermented liquors has been carried too far. It has p'\Osed beyond the legitimate limits of a fad, and is beginning to OS-time the proportions of a public nuisance and cause of injury. I honestly believe the propaga- tion of teetotal doctrines is exercising a destruc- tive influence on the moral, mental, and physical hetikh of the people and while this is not the place to adduce the fuli data upon which I base this opinion, I caorot hesitate to say that I think those whft take a regional view of the I great drink question ought to show the courage of their convictions. It is not right to give way, step by step, beforo the a,-gre-sive poiicy of the teetotal advocates. Those who have taken the trouble to investigate the question at issue, and have nrrived at a conclusion that doel" not accord with that which prevails at the moment, are not justified in setting aside their own views or keep- ing sslonce because, forsooth, the motives of their opponents fire good. It is possible to do a great deal of tiire mischief with the best of possible in- tentions but is this right ? I (like Sir Wilfrid Lawson) trow not,"

[No title]

___------_------_----_ THE…

POULTRY KEEPING AS AN INDUSTRY.

HOUSEHOLD NOTES AND REPLIES.

NOTES.

- REPLIES.

SODA IN THE KITCHEN-

[No title]

Advertising