Welsh Newspapers

Search 15 million Welsh newspaper articles

Hide Articles List

33 articles on this Page

---MINISTER'S SLANDER CHARGE

News
Cite
Share

MINISTER'S SLANDER CHARGE Action Against an Insurance Agrent. Forty-Five People's Alleged Espionage Before Mr. Justice Phi Hi more and a, com- mon jury, at the Swansea Assizes on Fri, day, Wm. Henry Rob son, B.A., Weslevan .iSi'iister, in charge of the Wesleyau Society at Neyland, Pembrokeshire, brought an ac- tion against Edward Siddall, 'nsurance agent, of the same pi ace, for alleged slan- der. The wordy complained of Ly the plaintiff and alleged to have been uttered by the defendant, were aa follows:—"I am toid that Mr. Robson is in the habit of visiting my step-sister, Lizzie, at my father's house, and believ it is fOT no good purpose;" also, "I am told Mr. Rob- 80D is in the habit of being about late at nipht with young girls." Mr. Moriey Sampson (instructed by Messrs. Eaton Evans and Williams, Haver- fordwest) was for the plaintiff, and Mr. u liers Meaner (instructed by Messrs. G. Thomas and Merriman, Pembroke Dock) WM for the defence. In opening Mr. Simpson said the defend- ant's step-sister, Elizabeth Ann Siddall, at- tended the Wesleyaa Church at Neyland, and a series of revival meetings were held there, when ministers of rano-is denomina- tions took part, including the plain- tiff. Elizabeth Siddall attended those meetings, usually held in the evening. On February 9th plaintiff said if anyone had Bprritual diffLulties he would be glad if they would gpeak to him at the end of the mrtm. At the con<m. Mr. Robson leit the chape! to see members of the con tfregation, and just after he left Elisabeth idddl came up after apparently been cry- icg. and plaintiff asked her if she had anv difficulty and a conversation ,"?{«,reTice to spirit^ •>tfers ensued. Mr. Robson "Va P with Miss Siddall. 3.1 «i>teen, so far her fatWs house in Cambrian-road "—a boot five minutM> walk. He remained for some few minutes outside her father's— about a quarter of an hour. This was the first 'ime he hao had a conversation with the girl outride the chapel. On February 1), Miss Elizabeth Siddall wrote to plain tiff with reference to spiritual matters and asked him to come and see her. He paid paetora. visit and was m the girl's father's hocao for about three-quarters of an hour, this being the first occasion he had ever beeu in the bouse, and on that occasion the girl'"? father waa in "the garden. Whilst plaintiff was thera defendant came into the room. Plaintiff said, 'Good afternoon," t-o wbd. defendant mads no observation, but Passed out into the garden. On Febrnary 16th plaintiff became 111 and on March 15th rei.TiiT.eu to Neyland. Speaking of the al- leged gland counsel stated that defen- dant, had accused plaintiff of being cut late at night with young girls and mentioned Maud Nelson and also Elizabeth Siddall. Later defendant modified be had said, and when plaintiff asked that ho aAcnld give the lie direct to anything said in refer ence to him defendant was not willing. Dc- fendant at first denied sneaking the words ar.3 said if tbev were spoken or published they did not have the meaning alleged and alternatively if spoken they were without malice in the belief they were true and un- der the cirrumstances privileged. Plaintiff had a conscientious objection to taking the oath and Tmed. Speaking of the service b, snid no one came to him at the conclusion in the chapel. When he Wf«■>* dov \i :ss Siddall came behind him and he saw she was crying. He bore out counsel's opening and said when he visited 1,r; S-VMalJ at her request defen- dant took no obi^^tion on coming into the rorm. Subsequently plaintiff learnt that certain stnt er;ts had been made in refer- ence to him which he heard from a Mrs Ben- nett It was absolutely false that he had bJ.1 oit laf-" with young girls. Beyond "he exception given he had never been out late with a eirl. Cross-examined: The revival meetings commenced on January 9th and he heard of the slander on his return. Speaking of an icterview with defendant, whom Mr. Harris hii choirmaster brought up, defendant said a. man named Williams had said something detrimental to his moral character. Plain- -m denied when Miss Siddall good catling her "My dear. Plaintiff did not remember defendant saying tuat he did Dct accuse pLuntiff ot immorality. Hannah Bennett, John-street, Neyland, epoke to the alleged slander, defendant men- tioning the names of Maud Nelson, Jennie Jones, and a girl beginning wit a an "M," or "V." Witness asked, "Is my daughter in »i?" "Well, no," defendant leplied, "I can't'say she's in it," implying, said wit- ness my daughter was one. Defendant said he had s, rdaintiff at his father's Lor.se on one occasion and he (defendant) made it hii business to "plunge in the house. ¡ Ia the front room he found plaintiff and h; half-sister there. Robson said "Good aft-f-nocn," but defendant eaid Le was too I much disensted to answer. The father, so it was alleged, said he knew the parson was I there, but he did not wish to see the -Defendant also said he timed his visits to. RiddaU's whilst his (defendants) younger brother was at school. Defendant also said he could mention f-mr cr five persons who had seen them together. Cross-examined Mifts Giclclal1 had told ^rtn-ess's daughter that she had had a con- versation with the plaintiff on spiritual mat- Mrs Witness had not previously heard rumours regarding plaintiff. Witness did w think Ssre «ras any impropriety in +*-« home with Miss Siddall. The^atter, she thought, Kd rather boasted 5. Defendant mentioned a conversation £ uh William Williams who had overheard the conversation, so it was gating to plaintiff calling Miss Sidaai! ..i,y dea.. Witness she did say that i. n<?r ter wai u- it e would black the plainttif 6 '^Har^r Nelson, sailniaker, said in the Iat- tpr part Of February Mrs. Bennett made „ .rLunir3t^ii to witness a wife about his SSter and he asked the defendant to oome and see him. Sidda came and Mrs. Nek'jn becan angrily, hlit, "dve%T y<\u W savinii about my daughter, Maud, and Mr."Tlobsor.. Let usknow a there ,s anvf ing in it." Mr. Sidd^ .said he was Icir he ead said it, but he had ocen told olaintiff had be^n visiting his step-sister s hous- and he (defendant) believed it was for no food purpose. Defendant, said he was told=by someone "Now, hoy, it you want to see anvthing go to your father's house, the'niinisiev is there." Defendant said he wen+ into the house and asked his father whv'he^allowed that man ir the house. De- |pndanf said he liad been told plaintiff was in th hahit of being with young girls late and Maud (witness's daughter) was one. V ness asked for the source 0] the rum- o, s," bin defendant would not say. Wit- ness'told defendant he should treat him as the manufacturer and cirenlator if the sean- ^*Crcss-cxa\ninedWitners had not heard -„„thin^ previously against Robson. M Flizabeth Nelson, wife of last wit- n-s^aid defendar.t's- attitude was such as to make witness i^lievc he had seen some- 'Y^sI-eSined: Witness askerl defen- dant what he saw at his father house, and he replied. "Nothing. He said the par- ,041 w s sitting down and his sister stand- in\Ir^ Meager, for the defence, submitted the communication made was privileged and that defendant had no motive.

HEALTHY AND STRONG

Mr Trueman's Action Against…

--------Mr, Evan Roberts at…

GALE AT SWANSEA. --

-------Y.M.CA. Gala at the…

Advertising

!1 IPontardawe District Council.

Fatal Fight at ftlaesteg..…

-------------------London…

Husband and Wife.

Advertising

South Wales iSaiiway Combine.…

=-------Suspicious Swansea…

Advertising

Main JColliery Report.

- ILate Mrs. David Batcup's…

,---...-.;--------..----,,…

.--.- I Ystalyfera Man Charged…

--County Council and Cockett…

Swansea's Infant Mortality,…

Advertising

I--.--1 Aberavon Hosts and…

Margam Annual Show,I

Swansea Case in Chancery,I

-------Penniless Swansea Chef,

-..... -'-------Swansea Street…

[No title]

Advertising

------------SWANSEA SAW MILLS…

Forgiving Father's Pathafcie…

Advertising

[No title]