Welsh Newspapers

Search 15 million Welsh newspaper articles

Hide Articles List

17 articles on this Page

------------------.----------TEETOTALISM…

News
Cite
Share

TEETOTALISM VERSUS STATISTICS. ANSWERS TO THE ALCOHOLISTS. p reply to the statistics which we published, setting torth the results of the Investigation Committee of the British Medical Association, touching the influence of alcohol and abstinence on longevity, several cor- respondents have rushed into print. Dr. JohnMoir, of London, says:— la?.t *8 very amusing to find that every now and again for the • T 0 7ears> a paragraph containing statistics compiled by "*yestigation Committee of the British Medical Association, »i e3v.t^e r,oun^ °f the papers, to show that th se who drink no .,Whftever re»c»J the shortest age, and that after them comes the drunkards. Then follows the five categories of the ILd"es not sav, as the Committee of Investigation did, J reporter, Dr. Xsambard Owen, has constantly written to paper after paper to say. that only V>'2 cases of total abstinence were recorded an entirelv inadequate number, that no record whatever of their life bisto-y is given, as to length of abstinence, whether with constitutions previously ruined by drink, or why they should not be reckoned amongst the faabuual !y temperate* iUhe only disease they suffered from was total abstinence! But *be Investigation Committee and Dr. the absurdity of forming any opinion on 122 cases Tami l bem- considered a general law, do say in the very same report, and as a part and parcel of the same table, and in explanation of it, that no conclusion unfavourable to wetotaiism could be drawn from tbe.se statistics, and that we "ave not in these returns the means oi coming; to any !r'^c 'on as to the re'ative duration of life of totai abstairevg habitually sober drinkers of alcoholic liquora." Bat common-sense, the statistics oi Life Assurance ( mces, such as ^Pe,, :ot-tisli Amicable, Sceptre, Wbittin.'jtoi., Gresoam, &c., and ?Ltf?e p-reat Benefit Societies, prove that the mortality iu the m, abstaining- members is just nalx tbyt of the non-abstaining. rt«.Jeport of t!'e Regisn-ar-G-enerui for 1885 shows that the Bath-rate of persons e»;,a<xed in tne retail liquor trade is four as high as that of the rriinisters, priests, and clergymen same ages. Mr. Thomas Wallace, P.8.A., in a paper tv! t 1,1 Edinburgh ii> 18:8, before the Actuarial Society, states mat the roovtaiit' per 1,009 of licensed grocers is 1S'9, of hotel 26 o, ami of publicans i>3'4, whilst the average ft>r bnglisi;men Generally is 10'IS per 1,<>00. Mr. Taific" White, of the United Kingdom Alliance. a'2.° rtplies and says «y dixit of quoting the figures and omitting the ea^jy •Portant context, some spokesmen of the liquor-selling claimed to assure the public on medical authority tuu otai abstinence has been proved to be a pr ictice » J aetrinaentai to health, and that abstainers as a bod/ rS Ke than habitual drunkards. The doctrine^ stated is fortunately preposterous enough to d f'"f.Js,(a bject. How preposterous it is the following {f t\ ow■ ^Uppose it were thought desirable to prove 1at oard Schools shortened life, a case muciiiD»r? able than this one, could, on this principle, be got ?L d rt °,f t )e theory. A number of doctors recordingi |-d^. hs tl'e tin at death of such of their patient* 1^ us and r^aIds asbad attended Board Scbf«'s' "K1 ^ave few t0 record; but the few would be those "nder 30 years ana the average age at death ^oul^ be more than *Sy 27 years while hat of per»° ,ei who bad not fended Board Schools would, ^on^f vfrf "1U('h higher. **«. on the liquor people's theor/ ot V]tal statistics, the Proof woui,i bg overwhelming 1 "Attendance at Board Schools fn'm the date at which lm* .Schools came into existence, we know that it is "^possible for the a»e,a' death of those who had ^tended these schools and had died after having attained the age of 25' t0 be anything like as great the average ai: death of persons over 25 n°t attended these schools. In the one case, the ueathB must have been those of persons between 25 and say 35 r„ '^e utmost; and in the other, of persons ranging from 2o the extreme limit of human life. Tbe same principle ap- £ 'l«s, though not to the same extent, to the matter in hand. wint?tnPel'anee movement {, }*nown, it is among the voting mainly that, during the siw'iUarter of a centurv especially,il has ee/' luflu^ntlal aI?J Hence it .s that, the proportiono eeo.Ilers in section of the cummnni'-v between 25 and 8a> 3o or 40» ^ously grelter than among that portion of it whose wf,\e«eedS5or40ve*rS. As there is no period of life at *h who die, and as the rate of r^v m ^;M^wer in early manhood than it is to find that amongst the deaths which have occurred would, in propor- '°n to the number of teetotalers living, be few, and, on the w«age. "w i.Id have taken P'iace at a relatively early as;e. cla°s ''0'"cl,ss' teetotallers ought 10 be compared with wurking- claa n°n"teetotallers, ouJ miadle-class abstainers with middle- inatt 9°n-abstainers, and so on. In the following table the r*te» are sunplied for a comparison between the death- thosp' at: var'ou» a^es< w'or^'n?-c!ass teetotal Bechabites and the m0t Working-class non-teetotal Foresters. It also supplies a»es eV18 comparinK the rates of mortality, at the same fiech' middle-class healthy assured males, with those of the ni es those of males of all classes. The table gives of ''ber of deaths per l,OoO per annum at the ages named, rtiaiC ites' y°r#stei's, healthy assured males, and Kechiv *1' England.' It should be read thus :-Of 1,000 26 ■ 0f ltes' a £ e -5. will die before reaching the age of the'an Foresters, aged 25, 7'370 will die before reaching bef0r 26 of •' iiealthv assured males," 6-630 will die all reaching the age of 26 and of 1,000 males of <;0 0^ngland," 7-7vy wjjj jje before reaching that age; and l' i\ Rate of Mortality j), Rate of Rate of per 1,000 per Mortality Mortality Bate of annum of fl Per 1,0)0 per 1.^00 Mortality "Healthy e per ammmlper annum per 1,000 Assured Male A». ln tne in the iper anuum Lives," according t Order or Order of of the to the ,U Kseuabiies Foresters Males of experience of 20 for f0r AH Life Assurance the five the fi*e En? and," lOfflces, collected years 4ars l971-80. by the IWj-83 i«7i-5 Institute of » Actnaries. '-1 £ 5*732 7-370 | 7'729 6 030 *i 4-057 8*070 9'SSS 7*720 i ,r 4"337 10*1.0 } 11*276 8*770 fjf 6-094 12 j 1S-S93 10*310 Ei 6*272 I5*lly IC-691 12*190 5c i>Sc0 {- 20-SSrt 15*950 9 60 12-^7 ;6*2..o j 2V *> 21-030 21 «5 ^'p1 'i3'66t) tf5-450 40 i1? 49-370 4a'856 43*4o0 C'

[No title]

Advertising

[No title]

.I " THROW-BACK » JOURNALISM.,

. COUNTY BOROUGH OF SWANSEA.

Advertising

! DEATH OF THE ARCHBTSHOP…

* NEATH AND ITS DISTRICT-

[No title]

- THE LECTURE ON EGYPT AND…

♦ — GILFORD HAVEN AND ITS…

[No title]

FIFTY YEARS OF LOCAL HISTORY.1

THE OLD DECEPTION' OF THE…

-* SWANSEA RrRAL SANITARY…

Advertising